Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems


by Sunny Hundal    
9:11 am - September 5th 2012

      Share on Tumblr

When it came to the crunch, David Cameron turned out to be more of a mouse than a man.

Yesterday’s half-hearted Cabinet re-shuffle was more a display of weakness than strength.

And what’s more, I suspect Cameron will live to regret it later, because he is only setting himself up for more dysfunction.

To give an example, the Telegraph reports today:

Michael Fallon, the Right-wing deputy chairman of the Conservative Party, was appointed Mr Cable’s deputy at the Department of Business. Several other forceful Conservative advocates of free market reforms were appointed to new posts as Mr Cameron and George Osborne, the Chancellor, set out to kick-start the stagnant economy.

Sources said that, in a calculated snub, Mr Cable was not consulted in advance on Mr Fallon’s appointment, an attempt to appease Conservative critics.

The Telegraph obviously enjoys kicking the Libdems, but I don’t suspect the latter will take humiliation like this for too long (though they’ve shown amazing capacity for it so far).

Besides, Cameron could add 20 more right-wing Tories to the Treasury team and it would make no difference. They’re all right-wing Tories who will advocate more supply-side trickle-down economics rather than accepting the real cause of the crisis: a lack of demand.

So the re-shuffle won’t make a difference to the stagnant economy unless accompanied by a genuine change in policy. But all this sniping will lead to more in-fighting.

Cameron lurched to the right in his reshuffle because he is weak and needed to appease the right of the party. He had no other choice.

But make no mistake: it will actually mean more paralysis and infighting in government, as Libdems refuse to cooperate on a wider range of legislation. To get his legislative agenda through, he needed to build bridges with the Libdems not recruit a bunch of minister who would love to give them a kicking.

I welcome the coming government paralysis – it means they will find it difficult to do more harm. Bring on the popcorn.

    Share on Tumblr   submit to reddit  


About the author
Sunny Hundal is editor of LC. Also: on Twitter, at Pickled Politics and Guardian CIF.
· Other posts by


Story Filed Under: Blog ,Westminster


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


This has got to be my favourite story regarding a new mover: Simon Burns, newly moved to Transport has previous convictions for running a cyclist over in his 4×4, outside Parliament no less: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/conservative/4449654/Tory-MP-fined-over-Parliament-car-crash.html

Once again the Palace of Westminster’s in house piano (the lib dems) have been played like a Steinway. We now have a health Secretary who hates the NHS and wants to break it up and sell it off to the private sector. Thank goodness the lib dems abstained when they had the chance to send Hunt to the backbenchers for the rest of this parliament for his duplicity in the Murdoch takeover. The so called party of principles is revealed as a bunch of spineless morons.

We also now have a equal opportunities minister who hates gays, and an environment minister who is a knuckle dragging climate change denier. How are those lib dem principles doing now? But the usual head in sand lib dem glass is always half full dimwits cling on, and spout the nonsense about “fixing the economy” Hows that going by the way? Double dip recession, another 10 billion in cuts to welfare, as Osborne doubles down on austerity.

I have news for the lib dems, even if the economy turns round, and it is a big if, you will get no credit. The tories will take it all for themselves. You will be blamed for screwing over the disabled, and the poor.

Never mind, you can console yourselves with David Laws. A man who stole £56 thousand in expenses from the tax payers. Imagine if he had done the same on housing benefits,? 3 years in jail? Instead he was banned for 1 week from parliament, and then a back bencher at full salary. Don’t you just love those Lie Dem principles?

All good fun stuff – but probably it won’t make much difference to anything, be it the country or Cameron’s leadership.

The right of his party will continue to agitate, his ministers will continue to dither (especially as a couple of rare non-dithers have been effectively sacked in Clarke and Greening), and the general laissez-faire principles that are so crucial to both Lib Dems and Tories will continue to dominate government thinking.

Rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic while shouting full steam ahead for the iceberg. Hunt promoted for being Cameron’s human shield during Leveson and extracting from Cameron the appointment of Bazalgette as head of the Arts Council (something Cameron was supposed to have been deeply opposed to according to Private Eye). Feeble Maria Miller promoted to culture where she’ll grin and go along with anything she’s told. Grayling, a serial liar, made minister for justice. IDS refusing to move from the DWP despite being the only one on the planet who doesn’t think universal credit will be a gigantic disaster. And still, the thickest, most charmless, ugliest man in the cabinet remains Chancellor, a man whose mathematical prowess was demonstrated by his promise to give 110%. However far to the right Cameron goes the right wing of his own party won’t be satisfied with anything less than withdrawal from Europe, the scrapping of all human rights, the abolition of income tax, the rebuilding of Hadrian’s Wall, the privatisation of air and daily whippings for the unemployed

What do the Liberals get out of it? The return of sticky fingered David Laws. Is there no debasement so gross and vile that the liberals won’t stand for? The only career left for Clegg is as a receiver in scat porn

No mention yet of the appointment of the new equalities minister who opposed gay addoption rights AND opposed legislation that provided for fertility treatment for lesbian couples.

Well played Maria Miller.

To you, Cameron showed his weakness by appeasing the Tory right. To the Tory right, he showed the party’s strength by ignoring the Lib Dems. I’m not sure there’s an indication that he’s lost power so much as reacted to changes in the balance of power in Westminster.

You only say he is weak and appeasing because you don’t like the decisions he made – but what makes you so sure that he would be more of a centrist if there was no pressure on him? Cameron has never shown any deeply held principles, only a desire to be PM. In opposition he was a centrist, in government a proper Tory.

The Department that ostentatiously sends out Bibles to schools, Bibles featuring both a preface by the Secretary State and a reference to his very person on the cover (why not a photograph?), now has both David Laws and Liz Truss as Ministers.

But it would be wrong to pick on one Department. In After The Party, a collection of reminisces published last year to mark the twentieth anniversary of the dissolution of the Communist Party of Great Britain, Andrew Pearmain writes: “I started sleeping with other women on my trips to London, other Communist students and even a Tory member of the NUS Executive whose taste for rough sex really shocked me; she later joined the SDP.” Well, she is not in the SDP, or even the Lib Dems, now…

John

The assumption in good political analysis is that a lurch to the left for Labour, or to the right for the Tories, is weakness.

The reason is that while leaders of both parties will come under pressure from die-hards and zealots to move away from centre-ground politics – centre-ground politics is centre-ground precisely because it roughly fits with what most people are comfortable with, and thus where elections tend to be won.

Elections are rarely won by following a policy path driven by one’s core support – because the core support tends to be more extreme and zealous than the public as a whole or business as a whole. It never does to listen to isolated special interest groups, even if those groups are your own political party.

Patrick McLoughlin

“Although a member of the NUM he broke ranks during the 1984 miners strike and later came to national attention when he stood up at the Conservative Party Conference to announce that he was a working miner”

“His career within the Coal Board was fast tracked to avoid a hostile reaction on the return of fellow miner following the end of the strike. Rising from belt attendant to Area Marketing”

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_McLoughlin

The last couple of years has shown the true face of the Tories. Never again will any Tory leader be able to pretend that the party has in any way shape or form been “detoxified” It never will be, it is what it is.

Their hard right, Thatcherite, eurosceptic, socially reactionary policies appeal to about one third of the electorate, and no more. Not enough to win a majority. To do that they need to convince enough people that they are at least semi-human, and dwell in the modern world. This government has completely undermined any prospect of them doing that, and thus of extending their support far beyond their core supporters, and of winning a majority on their own.

They have also destroyed any prospect of another coalition with the Lib Dems, who, assuming they are not wiped out will never touch the Tories with a bargepole ever again! Thus foreclosing the Tories only other conceivable route to seeing power again.

Interesting times!

@ Graham:

“Their hard right, Thatcherite, eurosceptic, socially reactionary policies appeal to about one third of the electorate, and no more.”

It’s deeply depressing to think that I’m sharing oxygen with something like 15m such uncaring, self-serving, xenophobic, sociopathic, greedy, reactionary sacks of crap…


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. sunny hundal

    David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  2. TeresaMary

    David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  3. Jason Brickley

    Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/6sfHuaCg

  4. BevR

    Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/KZpe2wTd via @libcon

  5. leftlinks

    Liberal Conspiracy – Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/4zlRZBbp

  6. Steve Hynd

    The gov't reshuffle will leave it with more infighting – @sunny_hundal says 'bring on the popcorn' http://t.co/iDoFINHm

  7. Rodney Willett

    David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  8. richardoram

    David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  9. Eugene Grant

    Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/KyOfGtzV via @libcon

  10. Eugene Grant

    Good blog by @sunny_hundal on why the #reshuffle will lead to more internecine in-fighting… "bring the popcorn" http://t.co/KyOfGtzV

  11. Natacha Kennedy

    #Cameron's #reshuffle exposes his weakness. He is a pathetic prime minister. http://t.co/P9wCnmvn via @libcon

  12. sunny hundal

    Why I think David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  13. MerseyMal

    Why I think David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  14. abi ramanan

    Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/d7jW5Nhs via @libcon

  15. Richard Alexandar

    Why I think David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  16. Antony Lerman

    Why I think David Cameron’s reshuffle to the right will cause him more problems http://t.co/VeEKbXfM

  17. sunny hundal

    Good blog by @sunny_hundal on why the #reshuffle will lead to more internecine in-fighting… "bring the popcorn" http://t.co/KyOfGtzV

  18. A socialist

    Good blog by @sunny_hundal on why the #reshuffle will lead to more internecine in-fighting… "bring the popcorn" http://t.co/KyOfGtzV

  19. Mandi Riseman

    Good blog by @sunny_hundal on why the #reshuffle will lead to more internecine in-fighting… "bring the popcorn" http://t.co/KyOfGtzV

  20. Elinor Predota

    Good blog by @sunny_hundal on why the #reshuffle will lead to more internecine in-fighting… "bring the popcorn" http://t.co/KyOfGtzV

  21. New transport minister was ‘fined’ for running over cyclist | Liberal Conspiracy

    [...] (via comments) [...]

  22. Collin Whittaker

    Good blog by @sunny_hundal on why the #reshuffle will lead to more internecine in-fighting… "bring the popcorn" http://t.co/KyOfGtzV





Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.