Revealed: Chair of inquiry hates regulation


9:01 am - July 3rd 2012

by Sunny Hundal    


      Share on Tumblr

Andrew Tyrie, Conservative MP for Chichester and chair of the Treasury select committee, has been appointed by George Osborne to chair the new inquiry into banking.

The government says the parliamentary inquiry will look into professional and cultural standards in the banking industry as a whole, and consider what ‘lessons are to be learned in terms of transparency, conflicts of interest and culture’.

The position of chair is key because they can guide the inquiry.

But Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all.

In 2000 he co-authored a paper titled ‘Leviathan at Large‘, which was written in response to the Labour government overhauling City regulation with the creation of the Financial Services Authority (FSA) (hat-tip @zwaaaa)

The bulk of the paper is focused on criticising financial regulation, with chapters titled: ‘The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘.

Here are some excerpts from the paper:

There will always be calls for more regulation. Every time something goes wrong, and particularly when it reaches the popular press, the cry goes out: “Something must be done!” This Bill is, at least in part, a response to recent well-publicised regulatory failures such as the Maxwell affair and pensions mis-selling.

It is all too easy for governments to encourage regulators to over-react. Governments cover their backs, but it is industry, the consumer and society as a whole who ultimately suffer. In financial regulation, as in so many fields, there is a tension between what is politically expedient and what is economically or morally appropriate.

The interests of consumers are intricately bound up in the interests of the City. If firms are driven out of business by the costs of regulation, it is the consumer who will be hurt by the loss of competition in the financial services marketplace.

The mobility of financial institutions
It is to be expected that major financial firms will be tempted to avoid the impact of an over-burdensome regulatory regime. If compliance costs become too high, large financial institutions can move, relatively easily, to a friendlier jurisdiction.

He specifically attacks the government bill as failing to “strike the right balance” and say it was “biased in the direction of over-regulation”.

Andrew Tyrie is unfit for the job of chairing the inquiry as he won’t be independent at all.

He has always wanted less regulation for the banking industry; we need a fully independent inquiry instead.

Sign the petition for an independent inquiry

    Share on Tumblr   submit to reddit  


About the author
Sunny Hundal is editor of LC. Also: on Twitter, at Pickled Politics and Guardian CIF.
· Other posts by


Story Filed Under: News ,top

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


1. Shinsei1967

There is a huge confusion between more regulation and good regulation properly administered.

Arguably setting up the FSA back in 2001 was “more regulation” but it was clearly far far worse regulation than allowing the Bank of England to maintain control over the banking system (as it had done successfully for many years).

Sunny was tweeting yesterday about banking “disasters” that happened under the Tory regime – Barings & BCCI. However both of these were criminal acts which had no bearing on the systemic banking system, cost teh taxpayer no money and were both dealt with efficiently by the BoE.

Many people are tweeting John Redwood’s report into regulation from 2006 which provides the backdrop to claims the Tories wanted “less banking regulation”.

Reading the report the only mention of any changes to actual banking regulation is to return banking control to the Bank of England and to make it easier for venture capital funds and micro finance funds to set up.

I happen to think an independent inquiry would be preferable though I think even a Parliamentary inquiry will root out most malfeasance. Tyrie’s chairmanship isn’t going to stop the other members asking whatever questions they want or calling whoever they want to question.

For a piece titled “Chair of Banking Inquiry hates regulation” you have unaccountably failed to quote from the chapter of that pamphlet titled “The need for a system of regulation”.

But competition has its limitations in this field. Such is the complexity of the financial service industry that individuals are forced to place trust in those advising them on, and dealing with, their money. The principle of caveat emptor remains an important one, but it must be modified to give those who deal in the financial sector a reasonable degree of confidence that the product or advice they are getting is legitimate.

Confidence in the market is essential to win global business. If there is a fear that a lack of integrity could prejudice an investment, that investment will not be made in the first place. The losses from fraud are not only to those directly defrauded. The whole market can suffer if confidence is eroded.

Opposition to the way that the FSA was set up (the pamphlet lists specific ways that the Bill could be amended, it doesn’t argue that it should be scrapped) is not synonymous with all regulation ever, and it’s sadly typical of Sunny’s Sidebar of Shame ™ that you should claim that it is.

3. Shinsei1967

Just as an example of how “more regulation” doesn’t equal better regulation – the FSA handbook is 6,000 pages long.

And yet it was the American regulator who took the lead in prosecuting the Libor scandal.

It should surprise no one that Andrew Tiresome (as some of his colleagues call him) is involved with the Thatcherite/Josephite/Shermanite Centre for Policy Studies.

Same answer as on the other thread.

Today’s banks represent the incarnation of profit-seeking behaviour when markets don’t work and corporate cartels are encouraged by politicians to exploit their customers. The answer to this is not regulation of the market processes which has been shown not to work. Instead, the market should have been properly regulated by the OFT over the previous thirty years to prevent the monopoly players developing.

But then, when the banks had over extended themselves with their “profit-seeking behaviour” and failed, Brown rewarded their “risk taking” by bailing them out and propping them up- once again subverting the proper market mechanism. I’m convinced Cameron would have done the same thing.

It is not lack of regulation that is the problem- it is the complicity of the state apparatus in market fixing.

I See the usual tory butler trolls out in force again. There is no low they won’t sink to in serving their masters.

Always priceless watching the pro law and order trolls defending theft on a giant scale. Self regulation is bust as a philosophy. Banks, Media Empires, oil companies whatever. Self regulation means no regulation.

If it works , as the tories claim, then get rid of of the police and ask burglars, shoplifters, to self regulate themselves.

7. Shinsei1967

@pagar:

“But then, when the banks had over extended themselves with their “profit-seeking behaviour” and failed, Brown rewarded their “risk taking” by bailing them out and propping them up- once again subverting the proper market mechanism. I’m convinced Cameron would have done the same thing.”

Spot on. And I’m sure you’re right that Cameron would have done the same thing.

The odd thing is that the more right wing Tories (who tend to be accused of asking for less regulation), such as John Redwood, would have let the banks go bust. (*) The banks shareholders and bond holders would have lost their investment. That’s how capitalism is supposed to work.

Greed works when it is matched by fear. No banker would take on 100x leverage if his own wealth was at risk.

This is what Sunny doesn’t seem to understand with his complaints at Tories lobbying for “less regulation”.

(*) Obviously the banking network (payments, cheque clearing etc) and all depositors would be protected by the government. The banking system needed to be saved not the banks themselves or the bankers.

8. White Trash

But Mr Tyrie has said: “I’m certainly not going to want to run an inquiry that is in any sense partisan or perceived to be partisan. And I wouldn’t be prepared to participate if that were the case.”

So that’s all right then.

I guess someone could ask Ed Ball’s to run the enquiry….I mean, he wouldn’t be biased at all would he?

10. Shinsei1967

@Sally

Not for the first time, in your eagerness to shout “troll”, you seem to deliberately misunderstand others’ arguments.

No one here is defending theft nor demanding more self regulation.

Quite the opposite.

As I said we need better regulation and stricter enforcement not necessarily more regulation.

The Bank of England managed to regulate the British banking system for 300 years very successfully. Through two world wars, fighting Napoleon and coming off the Gold Standard. However it had these controls taken away from it and given to the newly created FSA. Within ten years, and despite the FSA’s 6,000 pages of rules, it presided over the biggest banking disaster in history. The FSA and its rules-based coupled with bank self-regulation model was clearly ineffective.

There is also no need for further regulation if existing rules and laws aren’t being properly enforced. We have the Fraud Act and the Conspiracy Act which should be used to deal with the Libor traders.

As I have written elsewhere I’d double the Serious Fraud Office’s budget (currently only £36m pa, which is peanuts) immediately and set them to work.

Just imagine how much more of a mess we’d be in if we hadn’t paid all these highly talented, ethically scrupulous, gung-ho wheeler dealers and high fliers those telephone figure salaries and bonuses that would have choked Croesus….

…and all that light touch regulation really came up trumps didn’t it?

…I mean what could possibly go wrong….

….oh wait….

12. Ian Woodyatt

One set of legalised crooks investigating another group of legalised crooks.

There is a huge confusion between more regulation and good regulation properly administered.

Rubbish. Why don’t you give proper examples of “good regulation” that deals with the problem? And can you explain how any of this was “bad regulation”?

Is ensuring banks don’t get too big to fail bad regulation? What about separating investment and retail activities.

Right-wingers always play this ‘good regulation’ card but it means nothing most of the time. They would just prefer much lesser regulation

14. Shinsei1967

@Phil B

“Rubbish. Why don’t you give proper examples of “good regulation” that deals with the problem?”

I gave you an example of good regulation. Allowing the Bank of England to continue regulating the British banking system.

Banks getting too big, 110% mortgages and massive leverage all really started after the BoE had its authority taken away from it.

The trouble with a rules based system is what about all the thing the regulator forgets to make rules about.

Haven’t you noticed that the “left” (Richard Murphy, UKUncut, Michael Meacher) want to deal with tax avoidance not by creating another 6,000 pages of rules but by a General Anti Avoidance PRINCIPLE.

That’s effectively how the Bank of England policed the banking system for 300 years. Together with the normal criminal powers available via Fraud & Theft Acts.

Shinsei,

You are overlooking basic facts. The FSA was set up to deal with the newly emerged non-bank finance sector after the pension and mortgage frauds. These frauds were successful because the BoE had no authority to oversee these businesses, because they had to deal solely with banks as the reserve bank.

Tories have very bad memories when it suits them. They now pretend that the FSA was set up to take over the role of the BoE, but, of course, that is simply wrong. It was additional to the BoE. Naturally, politicians and bankers had their input and managed to get away with ‘light touch regulation’ which is now all Labour’s fault and ‘on with the corruption’ and ‘get rid of the FSA’ i.e. back to square one and fraud reenabled in the non-banking finance sector.

16. Shinsei1967

@mikems

“You are overlooking basic facts.”

Well, I was trying to simplify things. I’m well aware of the history of the FSA. I remember years ago having to pass exams on the Financial Services Act 1985 and SIB and FIMBRA and SROs etc.

The point is that whatever good work the FSA may have done in the retail sphere (pensions and mortgages) it was wholly ineffective at regulating the banking system. Yes, it was part of the tripartite regime, with the BoE, but it doesn’t take much insight to realise that making three separate people be in charge of something is less effective than one dedicated regulator.

“Tories have very bad memories when it suits them.”

That’s politics. I don’t recall any Labour politicians saying “we were just as much supporters of Lamont’s ERM policy as the Tories were and so we’ll take half the blame for Black Wednesday, as that’s only fair.”

If something happens on your watch then you take the credit or blame for it. Labour lucked out with being in power when globalisation and Chinese growth allowed ten years of low inflation global boom. The current banking regulation woes is the inevitable quid pro quo.

“‘light touch regulation’”

I’ve always wondered what peopel actually think is light touch. The biggest growth industry in the City over the last 20 years has been compliance depts. They didn’t even exist pre-Big Bang. How many compliance officers does Barcap have ? 100s ? You can’t move in the City without being registered and approved and signed off.

@ Shinsei

Greed works when it is matched by fear. No banker would take on 100x leverage if his own wealth was at risk.

Absolutely.

And it’s worth noting that limited liability for the directors of banks is a relatively recent phenomena. Would Fred Goodwin have been more prudent if he had known that the personal consequences of putting all the chips on red and it coming up black was a life on benefits?

I tend to think so.

Shinsei,

You are ‘simplifying’ things in the traditional tory way : rewriting what happened to more easily blame everything on your political opponents.

The main problem wasn’t the structure of regulation, it was the political surrender before corrupt interest.

Harping on, inaccurately, about the FSA and whatever is the same as trying to exonerate the corrupt players themselves. That’s why tories have used it as the scapegoat for banking corruption and crime : Labour can be blamed, real issues can be ignored.

‘I don’t recall any Labour politicians saying “we were just as much supporters of Lamont’s ERM policy as the Tories were and so we’ll take half the blame for Black Wednesday, as that’s only fair.” ‘

This is obviously another irrelevance and an attempt to blame some one else. However, to put the record straight on this issue, Labour opposed the rate at which sterling was linked to the ERM, not the ERM itself. But, once again, these trivial little differences can be ignored can’t they? It was linking sterling at 1.95 to the DM which caused an extended recession in the UK, and Labour rightly opposed that as did most of UK business.

‘The FSA was wholly ineffective at regulating the banking system. ‘

So it is all Labour’s fault, while tories were calling for less regulation and supported the Companies Act that made it illegal to try to regulate the FTSE if it was taken over by a foreign company.

All parties colluded with this corruption. Let’s have a proper enquiry, not this empty finger pointing designed to exonerate corruption for mere party interest.

I see you have dropped the pretence of being a liberal that you pursued for many years at the Guardian. All those comments with the obviously dishonest ‘but I’m a liberal, not a tory’.

Shameless really, isn’t it?

20. Shinsei1967

@mikems

“Harping on, inaccurately, about the FSA and whatever is the same as trying to exonerate the corrupt players themselves.”

I’m harping on about the FSA (rather than harping on about the corrupt bankers) because this is a thread specifically about regulation. Hence I’m discussing regulation.

I’ve already said upstream that I think the Fraud Act and Conspiracy Acts should be imposed on the bankers involved and said that the SFO should be given more money to prosecute criminality.

“This is obviously another irrelevance and an attempt to blame some one else.”

Hey, but it was you who “started this” by trying to blame the Tories for what they might have done had they been in power. I was merely pointing out that it is a poor political strategy. The buck stops with whoever was in power at the time. The good and the bad.

“Labour opposed the rate at which sterling was linked to the ERM, not the ERM itself.”

Very possibly. See now you are getting into details. Labour supported the ERM but not the specific rate. Yet you are happy to bandy around “facts” that the Tories wanted “less regulation”. But I’ve never seen the specific “less” regulation mentioned. Where are the details ?

Read Redwood’s “Competition Report” on “less regulation” and there is nothing in there about less regulation of investment banking. It suggests having less regulation for venture capital and micro finance fund set ups. It also goes on about returning banking supervision to the BoE.

You hope that just by saying “less regulation” you imply Tories would have had a complete wild west free-for-all. Yet there isn’t a scintilla of evidence this was what was being proposed.

21. Shinsei1967

@mikems

“So it is all Labour’s fault,”

I never said that. Where did you get that from ? I think it was a mistake to take banking supervision away from the BoE. And hindsight has shown that. However it was done with the best intentions I’m sure.

I’d say that the Tories probably would have managed regulation better because they tend to come from a City background and know the tricks. I suspect Brown was ignorant of City practices and relied too much on seemingly friendly bankers’ advice.

The FSA could have done a better job even within a slightly flawed system.

And obviously it isn’t the regulator that was corrupt, that was the individual bankers. But as I said this is a thread about the failings of regulation not the failing of bankers.

“Let’s have a proper enquiry”

As I said on my first post I think there should be a proper inquiry. And I was one of first people to sign Anne Pettifor’s petition on the No 10 website.

And I wrote an article calling for such an inquiry last Friday for Moneyweek. It’s on their website.

“the pretence of being a liberal”

What have I said that isn’t liberal ?

And I voted for Brian Paddick.

22. Shinsei1967

@mikems:

“All those comments with the obviously dishonest ‘but I’m a liberal, not a tory’.”

You should see the abuse and criticism I get on the Spectator Coffee House site. They certainly don’t think I’m a Tory.

23. PhilJoMar

Tell them they can have their parliamentary enquiry but it has to be chaired by
John Mann…

I’m a Labour Party member, I watch the Treasury select committee regularly for professional reasons. Tyrie has always seemed to me one of the better committee chairs and I think some of the criticism levelled at him here is unfounded. He seems an OK chap and doesnt come across as partisan.

Just seen the comment about John Mann above. John Mann made a fool of himself last week and he could have bothered to iron his suit as well.


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Liberal Conspiracy

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  2. freiahill

    RT @libcon: Revealed: Chair of Cameron’s banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/PoXq8roz #Diamond

  3. freiahill

    RT @libcon: Revealed: Chair of Cameron’s banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/PoXq8roz #Diamond

  4. andy

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  5. andy

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  6. sunny hundal

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  7. sunny hundal

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  8. Pete Phillips

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  9. Rosa Rubicondior

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  10. Joss Garman

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  11. Roblackenby

    "@sunny_hundal: Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/KrWOZ5Gp"That's it then. MT

  12. linnet1968

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  13. country supper

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  14. Roger Ivan Hart

    @mrsnickyclark The banking inquiry is already compromised http://t.co/GDJe5qvp

  15. sunny hundal

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  16. Juli

    'Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation' | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/lmQdIbNv via @libcon

  17. Bryan Collier

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  18. Stephanie Brooke

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  19. Jules

    RT @sunny_hundal: Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/x0nXT4c6

  20. John Hill

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  21. Mabel Horrocks

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  22. Christine Hill

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  23. PQ2 Art Prints

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  24. sunny hundal

    @markaustinitv I think Labour has legitimate reasons: public would find it credible, and free from anti-regulation bias http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  25. Brian Tomkinson

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  26. Jill Hayward

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  27. laura williams

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  28. sunny hundal

    @AnnPettifor Why we need an independent inquiry – Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  29. Ann Pettifor

    @AnnPettifor Why we need an independent inquiry – Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  30. Lesley Bruce

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  31. June Russell

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  32. Hurstingstone

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  33. Andreas Baader

    @AnnPettifor Why we need an independent inquiry – Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  34. Glen Neath

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  35. Ben Matenga

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  36. Sue Leam

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  37. zwa

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  38. Brian Tomkinson

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  39. Julie Gordon

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  40. Mark Carey

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  41. Wendy Bradley

    Sign the petition RT @sunny_hundal: Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/uk7VZFLZ

  42. Andy Henley

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  43. Chris Child

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  44. karen pearson

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  45. Tim Allan

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  46. David Kershaw

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  47. James McKenna

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  48. Heather McRobie

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  49. Paul W

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  50. thunder pob

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  51. Mark Howard

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  52. Kate Maclean

    How about instead of inquiry we get them all on Jeremy Kyle show, and he can shout 'Are you havin' a giraffe?' a lot http://t.co/qRKjG0Ba

  53. Liam Kelly

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  54. Summer Teh

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  55. Gary

    @AnnPettifor Why we need an independent inquiry – Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  56. G Phi

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  57. Mi Wae

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  58. Tim Bollands

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  59. HeyHo ~ Len

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  60. Mark

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  61. Peter Clarke

    #tippingpoint RT @tom_watson: I like Mr Tyrie but make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right person: http://t.co/9QFxz6jy

  62. Tom

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  63. Owen Blacker

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  64. Poison Popcorn

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/YglOkLcZ via @libcon

  65. Richard B

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  66. Adrian Mees

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  67. BevR

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/DCV99WTU via @libcon

  68. McDave

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  69. Brian Tomkinson

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/DCV99WTU via @libcon

  70. SyzygySyzygysue

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/oNLKRXUI via @libcon

  71. Jake Welsh

    Tory chair of Tory banking inquiry dislikes financial regulation. We won't hold our breath then. http://t.co/Q80rh0AD

  72. Rupert

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  73. Xanno M

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  74. Xanno M

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  75. Jean Rolt

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/cdKZbpQe via @zite

  76. Jean Rolt

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/cdKZbpQe via @zite

  77. Miss Mac

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  78. John Gillibrand

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/cdKZbpQe via @zite

  79. Paul Trembath

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  80. cutchswife

    RT @libcon: Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/PjUnRupd

  81. Steve Scott

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/oNLKRXUI via @libcon

  82. Alex Gallagher

    Andre Tyrie hates bank regulation. http://t.co/1RVwT1Lg Is he the right person to investigate banks manipulation of regulation?

  83. Deborah Sacks

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  84. Jennifer Taylor

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/cdKZbpQe via @zite

  85. Steven Mahay

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  86. Marc Geddes

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  87. Hank Spears

    Quelle surprise. RT @sunny_hundal Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/YR4MfDhT

  88. AMAPLtd

    a fair neutral and independent banking enquiry then.. MRT @sunny_hundial
    http://t.co/PhWtCm3V

  89. AMAPLtd

    a fair neutral and independent banking enquiry then.. MRT @sunny_hundial http://t.co/PhWtCm3V #Barclays #Diamond

  90. Anna Chen

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  91. John Rattue

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  92. Tim Hardy

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  93. Kanjin Tor

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  94. Annie Bishop

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/pWl5ufgU via @libcon

  95. Anna Chen

    Andrew Tyrie a cynical choice as chair of Cameron's banking enquiry since he hates regulation. @ed_miliband http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  96. Commuterist

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  97. Craig Williams

    URGENT. http://t.co/9rOaNzij RE PREJUDICED PARLIAMENTARY BANKING ENQUIRY. DEFINATELY MATES ALL TOGEATHER.

  98. Craig Williams

    URGENT. http://t.co/9rOaNzij RE PREJUDICED PARLIAMENTARY BANKING ENQUIRY. DEFINATELY MATES ALL TOGEATHER.

  99. Martin Abrams

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  100. Martin Abrams

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  101. Bleam

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  102. Bleam

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  103. Martin Abrams

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  104. Martin Abrams

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  105. Guy Lambert

    Interesting >>> @IntenseGas URGENT. http://t.co/mxl0CY52 RE PREJUDICED PARLIAMENTARY BANKING ENQUIRY. DEFINATELY MATES ALL TOGEATHER.

  106. Guy Lambert

    Interesting >>> @IntenseGas URGENT. http://t.co/mxl0CY52 RE PREJUDICED PARLIAMENTARY BANKING ENQUIRY. DEFINATELY MATES ALL TOGEATHER.

  107. Martin Abrams

    UK needs a full independent Judge led inquiry into the corrupt practices of big banks. Andrew Tyrie is not independent! http://t.co/kcckSsHp

  108. Martin Abrams

    UK needs a full independent Judge led inquiry into the corrupt practices of big banks. Andrew Tyrie is not independent! http://t.co/kcckSsHp

  109. Lady Kayla

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  110. Lady Kayla

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  111. Korenwolf

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  112. Korenwolf

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  113. Fiona McMahon

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  114. Alan Tilmouth

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  115. ntlk

    Beyond a frickin' joke! RT @sunny_hundal Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  116. sunny hundal

    @tnewtondunn @isabelhardman especially when bias of chair of the inquiry already known http://t.co/a6uEBwgG

  117. Robert Cook

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/vTw6EXrd via @libcon Inside job, for a change then

  118. Anna Chen

    @guardian "Libor inquiry All u need 2 know" misleading. U shld inform correctly that Andrew Tyrie is anti-regulation. http://t.co/sYOMOO5i

  119. TheCreativeCrip

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  120. Juli

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/JIwGOqj2

  121. Joe Ware

    RT @libcon: Revealed: Chair of #banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/8Wf0qkPA

  122. Philip Cunningham

    Wat? http://t.co/BhfyQV13

  123. Tim Hardy

    Added Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/UTXYzLBz to Articles of Interest

  124. Pam Lynch

    Oh come on, really?! WTF? RT: Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/zpoAYEyC via @libcon

  125. Richard

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  126. Pam Lynch

    The parliamentary inquiry into banking regulation cannot be independent given the bias of the chair http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  127. John Hurr

    Revealed: Tory chair of inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/WwJGrgEj

  128. bill bold

    @James_Macintyre Tyrie may be a good man but he's previously indicated his dislike for bank regulation: http://t.co/03ABxRvl

  129. Simon Blanchard

    Revealed: Tory chair of inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/WwJGrgEj

  130. Robbie Court

    Revealed: Tory chair of inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/lLaux516 via @libcon

  131. MattFinnegan

    Revealed: Chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/itrqEFNU

  132. Martin Campbell

    Why does Cameron want a 'short, quick, forensic inquiry' into #banking by a known opponent of regulation? http://t.co/hzRW0FUa

  133. Séan

    Revealed: Tory chair of inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/gRlDKnpc via @libcon

  134. liane gomersall

    Revealed: Tory chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/2cgXBZnp

  135. Gez Kirby

    Stacking the deck http://t.co/sKgUDoZ7 #fb

  136. glencoehiker

    Revealed: Tory chair of banking inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/2cgXBZnp

  137. Natacha Kennedy

    Parliamentary #banking whitewash – er inquiry, is already stacked in favour of the #banks http://t.co/ZcUJ9p3d #diamond #barclays #libor

  138. John O'Dwyer

    Revealed: Chair of inquiry hates regulation (libcon) http://t.co/pj9Dw7Xh

  139. Alan Hinnrichs

    Revealed: Chair of inquiry hates regulation http://t.co/l30AzQfO

  140. DJC

    Andrew Tyrie, Chair of the inquiry in the #Libor scandal, hates regulation, http://t.co/WHwiW3iy

  141. Andrew Crory

    Revealed: the Tory MP chair of Osborne's banking inquiry hates financial regulation http://t.co/cgMg49dq

  142. Casson McRae

    Revealed: Chair of inquiry hates regulation | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/DFscWkFx via @libcon

  143. Geoff Cook

    I like Mr Tyrie but read his words + make up your own mind whether Osborne picked the right lead on the inquiry: http://t.co/pQ15zumZ

  144. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Care Home Fees

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  145. Jayarava Attwood

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  146. Cab Davidson

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  147. ray turner

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  148. Chris Roberts

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  149. Gillian Kalter

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  150. festinagirl

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  151. Brian Tomkinson

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  152. jonathan hopkin

    'The risk of over-regulation‘, and ‘The danger of oppressive and arbitrary regulation‘. Andrew Tyrie in 2000. http://t.co/OhqQRAEE

  153. Anna Chen

    @FlamingoAlan Not sure about that but I wouldn't be surprised. There's this: http://t.co/dEglt7Qo

  154. V Bewtra

    RT @mattpearson: So the chair of the enquiry into bank ethics has written papers arguing against regulation. http://t.co/QtNaldIo hardly …

  155. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - How Does No Win No Fee Work

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  156. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Any Type Of Loan

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  157. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Example Of A Loan Agreement

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  158. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Example Loan Agreement

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  159. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Secured Credit Loan

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  160. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Low Interest Quick Loans

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  161. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Low Interest Secured Loans

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  162. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Quick Low Interest Loans

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  163. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Best Low Interest Loans

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  164. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Interest Free Cash Loans

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  165. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Bank Loan Quotes

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  166. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Loan Processor Job Description

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  167. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Job Description Loan Processor

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  168. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - 7000 Loan

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  169. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Application Loan

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  170. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Pay Day Loan Reviews

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  171. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Secured Loan Lender

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  172. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Fast Loan Lenders

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  173. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Short Term Cash Loan Lenders

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  174. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Fast Cash Loans No Job

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  175. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Job Description Loan Officer

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]

  176. Cameron questioned by MPs on eurozone crisis: Politics live blog - Short Term Cash Loan

    [...] • Sunny Hundal at Liberal Conspiracy says Andrew Tyrie should not chair the inquiry into banking. Andrew Tyrie is already compromised because he is not independent at all. [...]





Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.