Published: November 23rd 2011 - at 11:02 am

How Boris could do something about high pay in London


by Darren Johnson AM    

The Mayor of London is well placed to do something about high pay, which justly took up a lot of newsprint yesterday.

London is the most unequal region of the UK, with a fifth of its workers earning less than the living wage and a tiny minority getting inflation-busting pay rises year after year.

If the Mayor wanted to take a lead, one idea I’ve written up would be to set up a Fair Pay Mark – recognising companies that disclose their pay multiples and adopt fair pay policies such as those put forward by the High Pay Commission.

Twenty companies received over £9bn of public contracts from the transport, economic development, police and fire service services overseen by the Mayor in the past three years.

He could use this leverage to press them to sign up.

This could also reduce the upward pressure on senior pay in the public sector.

There were almost 100 people paid more than £150,000 in the Greater London Authority group last year, which was roughly ten times the London Living Wage.

The Mayor supported the idea of introducing a fair pay ratio. But he told me that he won’t implement it where he feels the need to compete with the private sector.

If he acted to reduce high pay in those companies he competes with, many of whom happen to be contractors, it might make it easier to hire a Chief Executive of Crossrail on something less than the £857,134 he earned last year.

In light of the autumn disturbances, the evidence that more equal societies are generally happier and healthier with less violent crime cannot be met with inaction.


---------------------------
    Share on Tumblr  


About the author
This is a guest post. Darren Johnson is chair of the London Assembly and deputy chair of the Business Management and Administration Committee. He represents the Green Party.
· Other posts by
Filed under
Blog ,Equality ,London Mayor


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


Althoughyou describe London as a region of the UK, perhaps you might do better to consider it as ‘the capital of the World’. Then, consider the impact of globalisation on inequality…

Meanwhile, who would you suggest runs Crossrail?

a Fair Pay Mark

Why would a company conceivably want to adverise publicly that it pays its executives less than the going rate? Talented people would go elsewhere.

Twenty companies received over £9bn of public contracts from the transport, economic development, police and fire service services overseen by the Mayor in the past three years. He could use this leverage to press them to sign up.

Ah, I see. You want them to be blackmailed into it.

Very liberal.

“Twenty companies received over £9bn of public contracts from the transport, economic development, police and fire service services overseen by the Mayor in the past three years.

He could use this leverage to press them to sign up.”

£3 billion a year eh? Or less than 1% of London’s GDP?
Some leverage he’s got there….

Why would a company conceivably want to adverise publicly that it pays its executives less than the going rate?

Why would a talented teacher want to stay in her/his job if their pension is being cut? Wouldn’t they go elsewhere? But you’re ok with cutting that, right?

@ sunny

Because their pensions would still be far better than those in the private sector?

I do particularly remember one of the guardian’s articles, when they used the example of a drama teacher with 7 years experience, working in a south london suburb on 32k pa. Bit of a fail there, given she was on considerably more than the median wage.

Honestly I would rather Boris just sat behind a desk and didn’t touch his computer, didn’t answer the phone and basically did as close to nothing as humanly possible until London elects a grown up to run the city. I wouldn’t leave the man in charge of a house plant. The best we can hope for from Boris is inertia, because if he does actually attempt to do anything it’s going to be an expensive disaster.

Once Boris is gone hopefully the lesson of not electing a mentally subnormal clown to a position of authority will have been learned. And it’s only cost us the lives of some cyclists and the biggest riots in living memory.

“Meanwhile, who would you suggest runs Crossrail?”

i will offer to do the job. I am sure I probably know more about transport than whoever gets the job, and I am perfectly capable of setting subordinates tasks to complete and managing their performance in completing them.

I will probably cost a lot less than the banker who will inevitably get the job.

8. Chaise Guevara

@ 2

“Ah, I see. You want them to be blackmailed into it.”

Refusing to deal with someone is not blackmail.

@ 4 Sunny

Why would a talented teacher want to stay in her/his job if their pension is being cut? Wouldn’t they go elsewhere?

Pensions are far, far less generous in the private sector Sunny. Has no-one told you that?

Besides, an experienced classroom teacher is only being asked to increase her pension contributions by £340 per annum. Hardly worth changing your job over.

People commenting on the above article seem to know quite a lot about the pensions earned by people working in professions other than their own.
Perhaps they can tell me what annual pension an individual who is a State Registered Nurse, now working in an administrative role (but after 40 years service, still employed in the NHS) can expect on retirement.
I am not emplyed in the NHS or any other publicly funded body, nor have ever been.

@ 10 barrie j

Perhaps they can tell me what annual pension an individual who is a State Registered Nurse, now working in an administrative role (but after 40 years service, still employed in the NHS) can expect on retirement

I think it is:

40 X 1/80th of final salary + a lump sum of 3 X annual pension.

That’s assuming 40 years worked (paying into the scheme) in all. If she (?) works longer it is ‘number of years worked’ X 1/80th.

For some NHS staff there is also a provision for taking a bigger lump sum, with corresponding reduction in annual pension.

Sunny, I’m a teacher and I stay I the job because the pay is very good in my opinion, the holidays are great, job security is excellent, I can’t really be messed about as we are well unionised, and day-to-day I don’t really have a boss. The only pain is OFSTED, the over analysis of what ‘good teaching’ is and the routine snake oil crap we get from every new initiative. If my pension gets altered, it’s not going to make me leave. After all, I’d hate to work in the private sector and have no job security, a pisspoor pension, fewer holidays and half-educated muppets with chips on their shoulders and poor grammar telling me what to do all day.

13. So Much For Subtlety

There were almost 100 people paid more than £150,000 in the Greater London Authority group last year, which was roughly ten times the London Living Wage.

The Mayor supported the idea of introducing a fair pay ratio. But he told me that he won’t implement it where he feels the need to compete with the private sector.

As if the tools in the public sector are competing with the private sector. This is a good idea. Too many civil servants are over paid. The rest is stupid. The idea we need some quango (full of highly paid leftists needless to say) to oversee pay is worse than stupid.

In light of the autumn disturbances, the evidence that more equal societies are generally happier and healthier with less violent crime cannot be met with inaction.

There is no such evidence.

14. Leon Wolfson

@1 – A demolition engineer.

@2 – You want the public sector to do it across the board. Can’t have skilled people in public service, after all.

@5 – No, they are not “better”. When you’re facing a pension which will never recover what you pay in, even, keeping cash under the bed is a better idea. That’s the reality for many of the revised pensions, for people working in high-stress jobs which materially impact their lifespan.

@13 – Of course there is, denial is not a replacement for evidence outside your NPD.


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Vinay Gupta

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/ZknW6Vru

  2. Pat Cox

    RT @highburyonfoot: Great idea from @DarrenJohnsonAM a Fair Pay Mark – see his piece on #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/zF13Wrqo

  3. Jenny Jones

    A Fair Pay mark. How a @Mayoroflondon could do something about pay inequality http://t.co/1Xkok4El #unison #Unite #n30

  4. Liam

    A Fair Pay mark. How a @Mayoroflondon could do something about pay inequality http://t.co/1Xkok4El #unison #Unite #n30

  5. Derek Wall

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/ZknW6Vru

  6. Lewis Coyne

    How Boris could do something about high pay in London | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/TReSIJQv via @libcon

  7. Boris Watch

    A Fair Pay mark. How a @Mayoroflondon could do something about pay inequality http://t.co/1Xkok4El #unison #Unite #n30

  8. Benita Matofska

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/ZknW6Vru

  9. Claudia Cahalane

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/ZknW6Vru

  10. Janet Graham

    How Boris could do something about high pay in London http://t.co/dVAoLYbD

  11. Camden Green Party

    A Fair Pay Mark: how the London Mayor could use his multi-billion pound procurement budgets to promote it: http://t.co/TCCQooG8

  12. camdenfb

    A Fair Pay Mark: how the London Mayor could use his multi-billion pound procurement budgets to promote it: http://t.co/NZvX1nIY #fb

  13. Joseph Williams

    Darren Johnson: How Boris could do something about high pay in London. http://t.co/m3o5N9RY

  14. The Green Party

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  15. Maeve Smith

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  16. paul and ron

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  17. TheCreativeCrip

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  18. Juan Voet

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  19. Barbara Hulme

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  20. Jacky Špalek

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  21. Flo McIntosh

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  22. Charmian Brownrigg

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  23. Bill Linton

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark My article on how to change unequal pay #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/bEDKJt7J

  24. Dominic

    A Fair Pay mark. How a @Mayoroflondon could do something about pay inequality http://t.co/1Xkok4El #unison #Unite #n30

  25. Green Party LGBTIQ

    How Boris could do something about high pay in Londony http://t.co/sZIEibu5

  26. Tom Miller

    We need Fair Pay mark, similar to the Fair Trade mark #liberalconspiracy http://t.co/XqLvU41f





Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

 
Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
LATEST COMMENT PIECES
» Students: help us demand accountability from University Vice-Chancellors
» What do we want from the BBC?
» The coming crisis of Conservatism
» Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods
» What’s the point of these justifications for the ongoing war in Afghanistan?
» The alternative: why Greece should NOT abandon the Euro
» For Cameron, looking weak is a bigger problem than being unpopular
» Most women don’t need counselling before abortion, shows study
» With Caroline Lucas stepping down, how the Greens need to change
» Advertising Standards Authority vs Archbishop Cranmer
» The far left versus the far right: French election part deux
» Our mental health services are a mess; can Labour change it?






42 Comments



44 Comments



53 Comments



64 Comments



3 Comments



27 Comments



14 Comments



33 Comments



25 Comments



28 Comments



LATEST COMMENTS
» Shinsei1967 posted on The coming crisis of Conservatism

» modernity's ghost posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods

» David Flisher posted on IDS facing defeat at the next election

» xtofer posted on The coming crisis of Conservatism

» Cylux posted on Why are gay marriage activists so silent compared to the US?

» Kojak posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods

» Graham posted on The coming crisis of Conservatism

» tigerdarwin posted on IDS facing defeat at the next election

» andrew adams posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods

» Churm Rincewind posted on What do we want from the BBC?

» flyingrodent posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods

» vimothy posted on Most women don't need counselling before abortion, shows study

» IDS Parole posted on IDS facing defeat at the next election

» damon posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods

» So Much For Subtlety posted on Students: help us demand accountability from University Vice-Chancellors