Published: July 15th 2011 - at 10:30 amEd Miliband ‘won’t back journalist restrictions’
Ed Miliband won’t back ‘draconian’ proposals to record meetings between journalists and MPs, a close aide to the Labour leader told me last night.
On Wednesday, David Cameron outlined the rough terms of an inquiry into the phone-hacking scandal.
One strand of the inquiry will be a full investigation into wrongdoing in the press and police, while the second strand would review regulation of the press.
The prime minister said he would be consulting Sir Gus O’Donnell, the cabinet secretary, on amending the ministerial code. This would require ministers to “record all meetings with newspaper and other media proprietors, senior editors and executives – regardless of the nature of the meeting”.
Cameron later told Ed Miliband that he would also consult on whether to extend this to journalists. “On transparency, I am consulting on the proposal to make much more transparent what ministers do, including not just business meetings, but social meetings. It is worth asking whether we should go further on meetings with journalists, as the police might want to do.”
However, recording all meetings between journalists and MPs would severely impede the work of a free press, said a senior source from Ed Miliband’s office.
It is not a proposal the Labour leader would be likely to agree to, added the source. Consider it DOA.
Bloggers such as Fleet Street Blues can rest easy.
---------------------------
| Tweet |
Sunny Hundal is editor of LC. Also: on Twitter, at Pickled Politics and Guardian CIF.
· Other posts by Sunny Hundal
Story Filed Under: News
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
Reader comments
I don’t see a problem with all meetings between elected politicians and journalist being on the public record (at least after the journalists have published). Isn’t the fact that politicians can anonymously brief journalists one of the problems here – that a you-scratch-my-back-I’ll-scratch-yours attitude grows out of this, because no-one else can trace the links.
A code limited only to ministers would be pointless – their SpAds could go and talk to journalists on their behalf – so what is the objection to this. MPs can and should say what they want to journalists – but they should not have the right to do so without their electorate knowing what they are saying.
However, recording all meetings between journalists and MPs would severely impede the work of a free press, said a senior source from Ed Miliband’s office.
Hmm. Would that senior source be an ex-political journalist by any chance Sunny?
Back to square one then ! What is wrong with Transparency and Openess because that way no person can be accused of wrong doing and we will not be back in this situation yet again.
Dont tell me that these people are just political point scoring and they do not really give a toss about the victims of phone hacking.
This has to be more than just getting one over that evil, deceiful, ruthless, hypocritical, liar David Cameron.
Press briefings are an important route by which backbenchers can have some influence and hold Government to account. The question is what effect these proposals would have. If they allowed Government power to become more entrenched I think we should be concerned.
Press briefings are an important route by which backbenchers can have some influence and hold Government to account. The question is what effect these proposals would have. If they allowed Government power to become more entrenched I think we should be concerned.
Fair point. But backbenchers should not be afraid to publically state their problems and views – that’s why they have the job, to be public. If their career aspirations outdo their ability to disagree with their party in public, do we really want them in parliament?
@5
If these proposals allowed ministers to brief secretly through a third party but required backbenchers to be named there would surely be an imbalance, don’t you think?
@6,
Not necessarily – because if journalists did not name their source MP, we would know it was a planted comment – and that would not look good when the expectation is for comments to come from an identifiable source.
Anonymous briefings work because they are the normal way to get information from MPs. If they were not, would they not merely be useful for hinting at stories to follow (a practical use – but one open to backbenchers as well) or attacking opponents without attribution (which would be a bit pointless unless there was actually a story to follow). In effect, any substantive debate on policy would have to be open, as anonymous contributions (says the person with a nom-de-pluie (and very poor French)) tend to be easier to ignore.
I just don’t see how this would be practical. Say you’re an MP and you go to speak to your CLP (or Tory association, or whatever), and one of the members happens to do the occasional freelance piece. Or you go to a party and a journalist is there. And what constitutes a journalist? Someone who has an NUJ card? The whole thing is a minefield. At least with proprietors and senior media executives it’s actually possible to operate.
Ed M seems to be totally right on this one. Firstly, a conversation between an MP and a journo could easily be entirely personal – you think MPs don’t have friends who qualify as journalists?
Secondly, the idea of recording casual conversations seems like a step towards something awful to me. If I were to be told that my conversations were to be recorded and made part of the public record, I’d want a very good justification for that. Saying “well, he’s a politician, and you’re associated with the press” wouldn’t cut it.
Thirdly, if we start taping everything our politicians say, the end result is that they get massively cautious, to the point where the PM can’t have a frank conversation with anyone in his cabinet. We end up in a place where the people in power won’t even talk to each other for fear of becoming front-page news. I don’t think that’s worth the payoff.
Reactions: Twitter, blogs
- Liberal Conspiracy
Ed Miliband 'won't back journalist restrictions' http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Innes @ Strathmore
RT @libcon: Ed Miliband 'won't back journalist restrictions' http://bit.ly/rmh2C5 << oh, good fr Ed. Ownership + regulatn. Not content.
- sunny hundal
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- steve conway
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Roxanne Persaud
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Chris Woolfrey
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Amelia L
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Edward Bearryman
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Rocki Stone
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Shelley Gooderick
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- alien from saturn
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- HeardinLondon
Just when he nearly said something good: Miliband will not back register recording meetings between journalists & MPs http://t.co/eOqoOSp
- Ferret Dave
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- James Tyrrell
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Jastinder Khera
RT @sunny_hundal: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs: senior aide http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Rocki Stone
@rayjoe Exclusive: Miliband not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://t.co/SvAKoES
- CIPR Public Affairs
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Nick Warren
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Praterstrasse
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- ToryKitty
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Tony Burkson
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- peter fainton
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Noxi
RT @libcon: Ed Miliband 'won't back journalist restrictions' http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
- Owen Blacker
Exclusive: Ed Miliband will not back a register recording all meeting between journalists and MPs, senior aide tells me http://bit.ly/rmh2C5
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
» Do older people really need more NHS healthcare?
» There are alternatives to the reckless ‘Plan A’
» On Beecroft: it is already quite easy to sack people
» Why Cameron’s claim of 600,000 jobs created is plainly wrong
» By using age to allocate NHS funding, Lansley rewards Tory voters
» The rise in domestic violence deaths is not an “isolated” problem
» Adrian Beecroft highlights mindset of Tory right
» The US is now a model for the Eurozone to save itself
» The IMF plan to revive the economy doesn’t go far enough
» The Boris brand is weaker than his friends think
» Nine things you can do to halt Lansley’s destruction of our NHS
|
48 Comments 93 Comments 23 Comments 51 Comments 10 Comments 26 Comments 23 Comments 69 Comments 44 Comments 25 Comments |
 |
LATEST COMMENTS » Chaise Guevara posted on Adrian Beecroft highlights mindset of Tory right » Mary Tracy posted on How Newsnight demonised a single mother » Chaise Guevara posted on Red Tory Blond: gay marriage "homophobic" » Chaise Guevara posted on Do older people really need more NHS healthcare? » Chaise Guevara posted on Do older people really need more NHS healthcare? » Chaise Guevara posted on '43% of young women sexually harassed' » Chaise Guevara posted on '43% of young women sexually harassed' » Trooper Thompson posted on Criticism of Obama for its own sake: a reply to Mehdi Hasan » Robin Hood: backed by the rich, backed by the rest, says new poll | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC posted on Poll: banks not paying fair share for crisis » Colin Hall posted on Adrian Beecroft highlights mindset of Tory right » re posted on '43% of young women sexually harassed' » steveb posted on Do older people really need more NHS healthcare? » So Much For Subtlety posted on '43% of young women sexually harassed' » Paul posted on Criticism of Obama for its own sake: a reply to Mehdi Hasan » Conby posted on '43% of young women sexually harassed' |
