Tories speed up plans to private NHS Direct too


by Sunny Hundal    
January 3, 2011 at 9:10 pm

The Pulse magazine reports:

The Government has announced it will rapidly expand the number of areas piloting the new 111 non-emergency telephone line, ahead of GP consortia taking control of the service.

The 111 phone service – which provides patients with a single phone number to access non-emergency care and will replace NHS Direct – is already being piloted in four regions: County Durham and Darlington, Nottingham City, Lincolnshire and Luton, but the Department of Health wants to expand this in England prior to universal coverage by 2013.

Not only is the pilot being rushed forward quickly, the provider may also change.

Health secretary Andrew Lansley revealed last month that GP consortia will be charged with commissioning local providers for the 111 service, offering the job to any NHS provider – including NHS Direct or private firms – under the controversial ‘any willing provider‘ policy.

(via @Richardblogger)

After recently announcing that NHS Direct would be replaced with a ‘cut-price service’, Lansley quickly backtracked in face of public pressure.

He said he had not announced plans to scrap NHS Direct, only to “phase out the NHS Direct number”. It is now obvious that Andrew Lansley plans to do much more than just change the number.

Not only that, he wants to accelerate the process of privatisation before its effects have been properly measured.

Only a few months ago Cameron said: “Conservatives will stop these pointless, retrogressive re-organisations and closures.”

Now even Conservative MPs such as Sarah Wollaston (former GP) are critical of their party over the scale and speed of NHS privatisation.

The Royal College of Nursing say it would be “shortsighted” to axe a service that had saved the NHS more than £200 million by dispensing advice over the phone.

Update: As LC contributor Ellie Mae revealed a few months ago, outsourcing firm Capita is looking to get in on the business.


---------------------------
      


About the author
Sunny Hundal is editor of LC. Also: on Twitter, at Pickled Politics and Guardian CIF.
· Other posts by
Filed under
News


76 Comments || Add yours below

  • We have a tight comments policy aimed at fostering constructive debate.
  • We believe in free speech but not your right to abuse our space.
  • Abusive, sarcastic or silly comments may be deleted.
  • Misogynist, racist, homophobic and xenophobic comments will be deleted.
  • Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy.


Reader comments


1. sally

So why don’t the LIE DEMS put a stop to this crap?

The pathetic, weak LIE DEMS have no balls.

2. Chaise Guevara

@1

“So why don’t the LIE DEMS put a stop to this crap?”

Possibly because the only place a party called the LIE DEMS exists is in your head?

3. the a&e charge nurse

John Neilson (Chief Executive NHS Shared Business Services) said moving some NHS services overseas would help in the drive to save £20 billion by 2014.

Call centres in India already handle invoices and other administration for some trusts at a fraction of what it would cost in the UK.
http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/nhs-wasting-1-billion-a-year-on-supplies-2174875.html

Presumably Neilson’s long term aspiration is to replace lowly paid overseas workers with snazzy little COM-PEW-DERS?

4. Bob B

Where will this new non-emergency NHS telephone service be located?

I ask because of this item in the news today:

NHS should outsource more call centres and offices to India to save millions, says top health adviser
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1343614/NHS-outsource-centres-offices-India-save-millions.html?ito=feeds-newsxml

I must say that I’ve had some excellent computer technical support from callcentres in India. One insight gained from experience which surprised me is that women techies are often better than the men. For a start, their language skills are usually better.

5. buddyhell

Er, shouldn’t the word be “privatised” not “private”? The sentence called for a verb not an adjective.

6. Richard Blogger

@Bob B

Where will this new non-emergency NHS telephone service be located?

Wherever.

Seriously, take for example the current out-of-hours services, that is commissioned by the local PCT. (In my area, the local PCT deliberately commissioned a private company so that the Department of Health – under Labour – would not think that it was unduly preferring the NHS. There were better NHS tenders, but the PCT realised that they would be seen as not using the private sector enough if they awarded the contract to an NHS provider. Dead Ed must do something about the Blairite obsession with privatising the NHS.)

Under Lansley’s plans the out-of-hours service will be commissioned by the GP consortia. As will the new, parallel, expensive, 24/7 service, that will replicate out-of-hours service and GP home visits. (All for the sake of “patient choice”.) In addition,
GPs will commission the local 111 service, and hopefully it will integrate (ha!) with the GP home visits service, out-of-hours service and the bonkers 24/7 service. It makes sense for the same commissioner to commission all four services.

However, GP commissioning as it is being implemented is plain daft. The current GP “pathfinder” consortia cover populations between 18,000 and 630,000. While it makes sense to commission a 111 service (out-of-hours, in-hours and the bonkers 24/7 service) for 630K it is plain ludicrous to commission such a service for a population as small as 18k. Consequently the tiny consortium will piggyback on the commissioning of a nearby larger consortium. Their patients will use the 111 service commissioned by the bigger consortium but the tiny consortium’s commissioners will get no choice. Bonkers. And it cynically takes the piss out of “choice” and “localism”. But we already know that this plan has nothing to do with what is best for patients.

7. Phil Hunt

The NHS seems to get reorganised every 5 or 10 years.

If all these previous reorganisations have made it more efficient, it must be approaching 100% efficiency by now, and doesn’t need reorganising again.

If — as is more likely — previous reorganisations haven’t made it more efficient, this one probably won’t either.


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Liberal Conspiracy

    Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  2. KateMcCandlish

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  3. Ellie Mae

    I missed a scoop! RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  4. Lee Hyde

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  5. Soph

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  6. Phil Makepeace

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  7. Ma

    RT @MissEllieMae: I missed a scoop! RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  8. Max Hernández Calvo

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  9. Liam McKee

    RT @MissEllieMae: I missed a scoop! RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  10. Richard Blogger

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  11. Les

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  12. kevinrye

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  13. sunny hundal

    Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  14. Andrew Collingwood

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  15. Trish Dever

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  16. DarkestAngel

    Tories speed up plans to private NHS Direct too | Liberal Conspiracy http://t.co/4bPKNmF via @libcon

  17. Eileen Allen

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  18. Joshuwahwah

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  19. Miles Weaver

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  20. Chris Roberts

    Tory scum not satisfied until a complete & total destruction of public sector. http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  21. Peter J Barnes

    RT @MissEllieMae: I missed a scoop! RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  22. Andy Bean

    RT @Chr1sR0berts: Tory scum not satisfied until a complete & total destruction of public sector. http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  23. Matthew Williams

    RT @MissEllieMae I missed a scoop! RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H #keepsgettingworse

  24. Farid

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  25. Pauline Hammerton

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  26. isla dowds

    @debbie_Abrahams #Tories push plans to privatise NHS Direct http://bit.ly/dH4m9H” 'pilot' was smokescreen in (cont) http://tl.gd/7tcgee

  27. Clarebella

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  28. Mel from Leeds

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  29. irene thomson

    RT @Chr1sR0berts: Tory scum not satisfied until a complete & total destruction of public sector. http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  30. Jos Bell

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  31. Michael Glasper

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  32. Mark Ryan-Daly

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  33. Graham

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  34. Katherine

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  35. Marie

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  36. Victoria Hubble

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  37. Joe Cassels

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  38. Hazel Humphreys

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  39. D W

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  40. Jillandgeorge

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  41. Steve Harris

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  42. C Holford Myerscough

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  43. Bored London Gurl

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  44. Kevin Paul Berry

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  45. Michael Haslam

    RT @johnprescott Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  46. Jill Hayward

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  47. aj

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  48. tonyisyourpal

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  49. Andy S

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  50. Cheadle Labour

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  51. Tom Stanley

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  52. Joe Royle

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  53. John Gillibrand

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  54. Rachel Skinner

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  55. Ian Bursill

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  56. Melenie FW

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  57. Daniel Pitt

    RT @sallymumbycroft: RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @rich …

  58. Mike Lloyd-Rourke

    “@johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon” remove the direct bit… ;)

  59. David Steer

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  60. Pucci Dellanno

    RT @libcon: Tories move forward plans to private NHS Direct too http://bit.ly/dH4m9H

  61. jbw

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  62. Gwendabird

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  63. Catherine Paskell

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  64. Nick H.

    RT @sunny_hundal: Tory MP Andrew Lansley speed up plans to private NHS Direct too – http://bit.ly/dH4m9H (via @richardblogger)

  65. paulstpancras

    Tories speed up plans to private NHS Direct too | Liberal Conspiracy
    http://bit.ly/ewneaM

  66. Marcus Chown

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  67. dean raybourne

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  68. John Prescott

    Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon

  69. Neil O'Leary

    RT @johnprescott: Looks like we're going to have to #saveNHSdirect again http://bit.ly/dH4m9H via @libcon





  • We have a tight comments policy aimed at fostering constructive debate.
  • We believe in free speech but not your right to abuse our space.
  • Abusive, sarcastic or silly comments may be deleted.
  • Misogynist, racist, homophobic and xenophobic comments will be deleted.
  • Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy.

 
Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
RECENT OPINION ARTICLES




How useful is Tesco’s u-turn on Workfare?
62 Comments



Watch: Obama sings the blues at White House
15 Comments



Why is YouGov’s Kellner endorsing the NHS bill?
23 Comments



‘Move Your Money’ planned against RBS
10 Comments



Rupert Murdoch cheers Rick Santorum to win
24 Comments



Labour: public pay won’t be frozen entirely
19 Comments



Revealed: That ‘dossier’ on Progress
17 Comments



Is Guardian as bad as Tesco on experience?
83 Comments



Bigots launch coalition against gay marriage
204 Comments



Revealed: other companies benefit from ‘work experience’
85 Comments



 LATEST COMMENTS
» pjt posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» pjt posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» pjt posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» Spike1138 posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» Paul posted on YouGov changes that deflate Labour's polling

» Spike1138 posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» Watchman posted on Workfare - what does the evidence show?

» Dave posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» Sally posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» the a&e charge nurse posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» cjcjc posted on Ten weeks to London's election: where Ken needs to improve

» TimJ posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» Paul posted on Ten weeks to London's election: where Ken needs to improve

» Watchman posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation

» Spike1138 posted on The real agenda behind Telegraph's abortion investigation