Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party?
On Friday I received an early copy of David Miliband’s Keir Hardie speech from an unusual source. It’s only when I read the speech I realised why it made sense I got it from them.
The source, close to Jon Cruddas, had co-written it. No wonder Jon Cruddas called it: “the most important speech by a Labour politician for many years” – it chimes with his own sentiments and the language is similar.
So let’s try and join the dots here.
I’ll start by saying I haven’t spoken to anyone from Jon Cruddas’ team about this article simply because it is a hunch. But it’s a strong hunch.
Both Ed and David Miliband have endorsed the idea of a chair for the Labour Party. But neither have expressed a preference.
Jon Cruddas recently rejected the idea of running for leader of the Labour party and said instead:
Those results, in an election that was supposed to deliver a hammer blow to the Labour party, made me more determined than ever to help create a national party rooted in the culture of organising that these local examples signify. Refocusing the party machine, turning the party outwards to the communities we seek to represent, rebuilding our internal democracy and ending the stranglehold of unelected officials are urgent and immediate tasks.
That would basically be the job of the Labour Party chair.
I’m assuming Jon Cruddas wants to be the Labour equivalent of the Democratic party’s Governor Howard Dean, who – after losing the 2004 bid to be leader – became a favourite of the party base and went on to be elected the party’s chair. There he laid down the ’50 state strategy’, which was vital for Obama’s campaign.
So how does this fit in with David Miliband?
David has already endorsed the idea of model of community organising that Cruddas favours. His campaign plans to train up to 1,000 community organisers which won’t just be focusing on winning him the nomination, but also on re-building local Labour networks across the country.
Having Cruddas as chair would be immensely helpful to both of the Milibands. It would make it easier for either of them to move to the centre closer to the election while Cruddas reaches out to the left-wing base of the party.
Regular readers will know I’m a fan of Jon Cruddas. This not only makes strategic sense but I think he would make an excellent chair of the party. Labour needs to be rebuilt from ground up and through a model of community organising that his campaign ran successfully in Dagenham. Now they need to replicate that model across the country.
I’m informed however, that Ed Miliband and Jon Cruddas, while being ideologically closer, don’t get on so well personally. But if push comes to shove they are likely to overcome personal differences and go along because this strategy makes sense.
But it seems that David Miliband, with the Keir Hardie speech, has gone the furthest in actively courting Jon Cruddas (I doubt the latter will endorse anyone in the campaign – or even if he does it will be one of the Milibands). I’m guessing it’s a sign of things to come.
---------------------------
| Tweet |
Sunny Hundal is editor of LC. Also: on Twitter, at Pickled Politics and Guardian CIF.
· Other posts by Sunny Hundal
Filed under
Blog ,Labour party ,Westminster
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
Reader comments
My understanding is that Cruddas supported David Miliband from the start, and that’s one reason why he didn’t stand himself. To me, that says more about Cruddas than Miliband.
And yes, of course he wants to be Labour Party Chair, he’s wanted that for ages & that’s presumably why DM said early in the campaign that there should be an elected Chair (and that’s all he’s said on party democracy, I think).
classic dot joining there Sunny.
But is the rift between EdMil and Cruddas the reason why the latter has not hedged his bets (a sensible act if both Miliband brothers support a chair). Should his team not now write a speech for Ed Miliband (help me out, I don’t know when his next one is or where) and Cruddas be complimentary of that.
I mean, if Cruddas is speaking nice words about David Miliband then Cruddas is obviously a good liar, why can’t he put his differences with EdMil behind him and wax nice about him?
I’m not liking all this dishonesty by the way, it is very unpoliticianlike.
endorsed the idea of a chair for the Labour Party
there should be an elected Chair
Isn’t there already a party chair/man? Last I heard, Harriet Harman was it, under Brown as Leader.
The links between Cruddas and Miliband’s historical narrative of Hardie and Labour’s origins are explored at length in this post, which offers a heretical challenge to both of them, in arguing that Hardie was considerably more engaged in the politics of progressive alliances and much more dependent on Lab-Lib links between the fledgling Labour party and the Liberals than either acknowledges.
http://www.nextleft.org/2010/07/so-how-far-did-keir-hardie-reject-lib.html
That seems to me simply a matter of the historical record, whatever view one takes of Labour strategy now, but I would draw a contemporary warning from it.
“Labour does have a suspicion of political alliances and entanglements which often runs much deeper than it does for Liberals or Conservatives. Ramsay MacDonald’s betrayal of 1931 retains an important symbolic role, and so reinforces the tendency to turn Keir Hardie into a plaster saint, a polar opposite, always rejecting alliances as a dilution of socialist principle. So the party instinctively feels that the new Con-Lib Coalition will help to clarifying an adversarial choice. Perhaps. Yet, in the long-run, it seems unlikely that the deep and gradual shift to increased pluralism in British politics over the last thirty years will be sharply reversed. If that does prove to be the case, enshrining Labour’s historic aversion to political alliances into a proud shibboleth of integrity, even at the price of impotence, could prove a costly mistake, particularly when it can be shown that Labour’s founding father demonstrated rather more flexibility and pragmatism in pursuing the cause”.
I also suggest that the specific example of Keir Hardie a century ago may today perhaps be of most relevance to the Green Party, with a parliamentary party of one.
Is Jon Cruddas making a ploy to be Chair of the Labour Party and if so is this a good thing?
If true I’d say it’s about the best thing to happen to the party in years. Cruddas, almost alone amongst leading Labour figures recognised the need to get back to the grassroots while the party hierarchy was still spinning its way to oblivion.
Only a return to being a democratic, bottom up movement can begin the long and painful process of reconnecting the Labour Party with the core vote it so cynically took for granted during the Blair years.
Reactions: Twitter, blogs
- Liberal Conspiracy
Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- Joseph Barnsley
@SteveAkehurst http://tinyurl.com/37wnqzl
- Izzy Boggild-Jones
RT @libcon Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9Obav4
- Ellie Russell
RT @libcon: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- Richard Budden
@ellierussell RT @libcon: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia <— I bloody hope so!!!
- B Latif
That is the obvious conclusion. Why not?
RT @libcon: Is Jon #Cruddas positioning to become #chair of the #Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia - Paul Sandars
RT @EllieRussell: RT @libcon: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- Steve Ainsworth
I sincerely hope so. I might rejoin. RT @libcon: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- James Easy
RT @EllieRussell: RT @libcon: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- sunny hundal
Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- Adam White
RT @sunny_hundal: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia > nicely put Sunny, totally agree.
- Arran Russell
RT @sunny_hundal: Is Jon Cruddas positioning to become chair of the Labour party? http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- Arran Russell
@TomBage it might be so according to @sunny_hundal http://bit.ly/9mEQia
- Peterward
- Neil Wigglesworth
RT @peterward2008 @Neilwigg
http://liberalconspiracy.org/2010/07/12/is-jon-cruddas-positioning-to-become-chair-of-the-labour-party/ < ? - sunny hundal
I made this argument after Kier Hardie lecture – before Cruddas said he wanted to be chair http://bit.ly/9mEQia
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
» What do we want from the BBC?
» The coming crisis of Conservatism
» Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods
» What’s the point of these justifications for the ongoing war in Afghanistan?
» The alternative: why Greece should NOT abandon the Euro
» For Cameron, looking weak is a bigger problem than being unpopular
» Most women don’t need counselling before abortion, shows study
» With Caroline Lucas stepping down, how the Greens need to change
» Advertising Standards Authority vs Archbishop Cranmer
» The far left versus the far right: French election part deux
» Our mental health services are a mess; can Labour change it?
|
42 Comments 44 Comments 53 Comments 64 Comments 3 Comments 27 Comments 14 Comments 33 Comments 25 Comments 28 Comments |
LATEST COMMENTS » Shinsei1967 posted on The coming crisis of Conservatism » modernity's ghost posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods » David Flisher posted on IDS facing defeat at the next election » xtofer posted on The coming crisis of Conservatism » Cylux posted on Why are gay marriage activists so silent compared to the US? » Kojak posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods » Graham posted on The coming crisis of Conservatism » tigerdarwin posted on IDS facing defeat at the next election » andrew adams posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods » Churm Rincewind posted on What do we want from the BBC? » flyingrodent posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods » vimothy posted on Most women don't need counselling before abortion, shows study » IDS Parole posted on IDS facing defeat at the next election » damon posted on Others should follow the Cooperative in boycotting Israeli settlement goods » So Much For Subtlety posted on Students: help us demand accountability from University Vice-Chancellors |










