Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away


by Sunny H    
February 2, 2010 at 4:45 pm

We noted on LC this morning that Lord Stern, who is a strong critic of climate change deniers, was to be named as George Osborne today as an advisor.

Lord Stern has said this in the past:

Those who say that climate change doesn’t exist are being understood as the flat-earthers that they are, as the people who deny the link between smoking and cancer, as the people who denied the link between HIV and AIDS.

Nevertheless, in order to shore up their green credentials, George Osborne announced that Lord Stern would help the Tories develop ideas for a new Green Investment bank.

But Sky News is now reporting:

Nicholas Stern, a highly influential crossbench peer who has played a key part in creating the Government’s global warming policy, says he will be working not just with the Tories, but also with Labour and anyone else who is interested. “I should stress that I am not, and have no plans to be, an adviser to any political party,” Lord Stern said in a statement.

“I would be willing to speak to the Conservatives’ advisory group about their ideas for a Green Investment Bank, just as I am continuing to contribute to discussions with the Labour Government about policies on climate change.”

While not ruling out working with the Tories, the suggestion earlier that Tories had ‘poached him’ now look decidedly premature.

Is Lord Stern backing from the Tories after discovering the extent of their climate change denialism?

Update
Left Foot Forward illustrates how the gaffe played out on TV

                Post to del.icio.us

· About the author: Sunny Hundal is editor of Liberal Conspiracy. He works full time as a journalist, commentator, blogger, activist and general layabout. He was voted Guardian blogger of the year in 2006. Also at: Pickled Politics, on Twitter and Comment is free.

· Other posts by Sunny H

· Filed under: news


24 Comments in response   ||  



Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. sunny hundal

    Is Lord Stern backing away from red-faced Osborne because of Tory climate change denialism? http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  2. House Of Twits

    RT @pickledpolitics Is Lord Stern backing away from red-faced Osborne because of Tory climate change denialism? http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  3. Nick Entwistle

    RT @OllyDeed: Tories fit for Government? They're not even fit for opposition. Another botched announcement! http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  4. Daniel Selwood

    RT @libcon: Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  5. George Allwell

    Liberal Conspiracy » Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away http://bit.ly/b128wb

  6. andrew

    Liberal Conspiracy » Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away: About the author: Sunny Hundal is editor of Li… http://bit.ly/aY7Idg

  7. Roy Bailey

    RT @tchee RT @OllyDeed: Tories fit for Government? They're not even fit for opposition. Another botched announcement! http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  8. Liberal Conspiracy

    Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  9. novocastrianrob

    RT @libcon: Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  10. Oliver Deed

    Tories fit for Government? They're not even fit for opposition. Another botched announcement! http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  11. Tracey Cheetham

    RT @OllyDeed: Tories fit for Government? They're not even fit for opposition. Another botched announcement! http://bit.ly/dzcTEk

  12. uberVU - social comments

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by libcon: Osborne red-faced after Lord Stern backs away http://bit.ly/dzcTEk…

  13. Osborne's climate gaffe | Left Foot Forward

    [...] Liberal Conspiracy also have the story. Share | Permalink | Leave a comment Click here to cancel reply. [...]



Reader comments

Oh dear, so so very sad that the Tories by this unbelievably stupid act of wanting to recruit Lord Stern have blown the possibility that we and others (according to many comments on the internet) would vote for them at the next election.

Stern’s report was comprehensively taken to pieces by acknowledged experts. For example, Professor Richard Tol of both Hamburg and Carnegie Mellon Universities is one of the world’s leading environmental economists and is quoted as an authority by Stern no less than 63 times in his report, said of Stern’s report that “If a student of mine were to hand in this report as a Masters thesis, perhaps if I were in a good mood I would give him a ‘D’ for diligence; but more likely I would give him an ‘F’ for fail.There is a whole range of very basic economics mistakes that somebody who claims to be a Professor of Economics simply should not make” (The Investigation, BBC Radio 4). However Stern gave the government what it wanted and that was all that was important !!!

Last Saturday we read yet something else: Information had to be quietly removed from Stern’s report on the cost of climate change after its initial publication because supporting scientific evidence could not be found.

Stern is a total greenie riding on its bandwagon and doing very nicely out of it – thank you very much. He has heaped abuse on those who question the extent of human-induced global warming scam.

When the whole IPCC fiasco is now unravelling the Tories do this. Instead of building on the revelations about the fraud and the manipulation of data and the lining of their own nests and the deceit etc which are coming out thick and fast every day – they do this. It is utterly beyond comprehension

Labour, Libs and Tories have all blown it. That leaves us in such a quandary about voting as all mainstream options have now been removed.

Political satire – outstanding.

BREAKING NEWS…BREAKING NEWS…BREAKING NEWS
In tomorrows news, Cameron will announcing his new advisor for the upcoming department of families, morals and scientific progress, ladies and gentleman, I give you – The Pope.

(later statement from AP) –

OTHER BREAKING NEWS…

The Pope seeks to distance himself from The Tory Party, claiming to never support the ideals of a man with a history of side-stepping questions about cocaine use and cannabis smoking, ladies and gentleman, I’m talking about, Family Dave)

“Is Lord Stern backing from the Tories after discovering the extent of their climate change denialism?”

I don’t think so. I just think he wants to remain independent of political parties.

The Tories have to win the middle ground to win the election. I think being seen to be Green is a key part of their strategy. They might lose some cc deniers to UKIP, but they can live with that. It is the middle ground they can’t afford to lose. I would hope that once in power they will have more access to scientific advisors and more of them will recognise the reality of climate change. Maybe this is a good time remind the grass-roots that Margaret Thatcher was one of the first politicians to take climate change seriously:

http://www.margaretthatcher.org/speeches/displaydocument.asp?docid=108237

(I now predict that a cc denialist will repeat the usual guff about Thatcher only using climate change as a weapon against the bolshy miners).

Oh dear, so so very sad that the Tories by this unbelievably stupid act of wanting to recruit Lord Stern have blown the possibility that we and others (according to many comments on the internet)

“according to many comments on the internet??” – hahah! Brilliant.
Please please – keep up your tin-foil hat wearing wingnuttery – I want nothing more than to see the Tories tear themselves apart on this issue.

#4

Don’t get me wrong, I’d love to see the Tories fall apart on this issue, or on any issue. But I’d actually prefer it if they took climate change seriously. Maybe we’ll regret that the pace of change forced by this government wasn’t great enough (though I’d argue that it is slightly higher a priority for the government than for the public at large), but if we get 10 years of a denialist government, that could be game over. Of course, I’ll be working to stop that from happening, but just in case it doesn’t, I welcome the Tories listening to Stern.*

* that’s if they’ll still listen to him, now he’s made it clear he wants to be impartial and there’s no publicity coup in it for them

but if we get 10 years of a denialist government, that could be game over.

Not necessarily. I think a Tory govt will talk about the environment but do little as it’s merely a cosmetic exercise.

That would be bad for Britain of course, in terms of jobs, technology and energy security but that’s the Tories for you.

I have more faith in Obama’s drive and willingness to push for change on the issue. In terms of global emissions and leading the way, he’ll have more impact.

#6

Not sure about that. As slow as the pace has been, Britain has punched above its weight in pushing this forward on an international stage. The US public will hold Obama back, and he may have only one term (hope not, but it is possible).

“Britain has punched above its weight in pushing this forward on an international stage.”

If the experience in London’s anything to go by, that stops when the Tories get in. They make the right noises, but the hamster’s wheel isn’t connected to anything.

The question now is, which will be the next Tory economic policy to fall to bits. It has gone from taking months for policy desintergration, to days, to hours and today it went in minutes.

How many self destruct buttons can one party hit in a matter of days?

http://redrag1.blogspot.com/

So, the pre-gaffe Tory position was:

Lord Stern of Brentford, author of a landmark study on climate change, will advise a Tory working group on the creation of Britain’s first Green Investment Bank.

But this was blown away when Lord Stern, in a staggering volte-face said

I would be willing to speak to the Conservatives’ advisory group about their ideas for a Green Investment Bank

Cor, what a humiliation for the Tories eh? Someone who had been going to advise a Tory working group now says that all he’ll do is, um, advise a Tory working group.

Nick Stern already has an owner,

Jeremy Grantham

Grantham Institute for Climate Change

In fact, it (Grantham) refers to the wealthy chairman of GMO, a large investment management company: Jeremy Grantham. Grantham has donated £12million to the London School of Economics (LSE) to fund the institute. He has also forked out another £12million to Imperial College London for the similarly named Grantham Institute for Climate Change (1)

No wonder, then, that the chair of LSE, Howard Davies – once the head of the Financial Services Authority and a former deputy governor of the Bank of England – was more than a little fawning over the ‘extremely generous’ Grantham. The new LSE institute will be headed by Lord Nicholas Stern, author of the UK government-commissioned report.

http://www.spiked-online.com/index.php?/site/article/5799/

Jeremy Grantham is the Chairman of the Board of Grantham Mayo Van Otterloo, an American investor well known among institutional investors, but relatively unknown to retail investors. He is regarded as a highly knowledgeable investor in various stock bond and commodity markets. Grantham started one of the world’s first index funds in the early 1970s and currently manages approximately $120 billion US.[

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Grantham

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

 
Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or rss feeds.
Recent articles across Liberal Conspiracy
LibCon news

8 Comments 18 Comments 15 Comments 20 Comments 10 Comments 26 Comments 57 Comments 67 Comments 2 Comments 49 Comments

click here!



LATEST COMMENTS
» crusade posted on Against multiculturalism

» 5cc posted on Against multiculturalism

» 5cc posted on Against multiculturalism

» ukliberty posted on Vote Pirate Party

» ukliberty posted on Vote Pirate Party

» Thebee posted on Tories offer state funding to schools linked to 'occult society'

» Just Visiting posted on Against multiculturalism

» Just Visiting posted on Against multiculturalism

» Matt Munro posted on Vote Pirate Party

» Thebee posted on Tories offer state funding to schools linked to 'occult society'

» Daniel Hoffmann-Gill posted on Contra Stimulus!

» Friend posted on Dizzy in a tizzy over MP's invoice

» 5cc posted on Against multiculturalism

» Lee Griffin posted on Against multiculturalism

» Lee Griffin posted on Against multiculturalism

  Last 50 // Comments feed