What exactly is Conservative economic policy?


by Paul Cotterill    
February 1, 2010 at 9:01 am

I’m simply not clear on Conservative economic policy in relation to government debt.

Why is Cameron saying to business leaders one day that there is no need for big cuts in the first year of a Conservative government, while on the very same day one of his top MPs is going on about the ‘need to get to grips with public finances now’?

Why is there a commitment to an emergency budget if there are aren’t going to be any significant cuts?

Would such a budget simply be about reducing corporation tax and therefore increasing the deficit?

Well, there is a track record for such economic stupidity by the Tories.

Under Thatcher, cyclical borrowing costs caused by the Tory response to recession – itself largely driven by fear of how the markets might respond – continued to ensure that the structural budget deficit continued at more or less the same level for a further four years beyond the actual recession (graphs at page 7 of this IFS report).

And the Tories are trying to instill economic confidence with international investors? Gawd help us.


---------------------------
     


About the author
Paul Cotterill is a regular contributor, and blogs more regularly at Though Cowards Flinch, an established leftwing blog and emergent think-tank. He currently has fingers in more pies than he has fingers, including disability caselaw, childcare social enterprise, and cricket.
· Other posts by
Filed under
Blog ,Economy ,Humour


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


1. Mike Killingworth

Not only that, but the emergency budget immediately after the election is the only window politically for cuts of the size the Tories say will be needed.

Let’s just remind ourselves what those are:

- making all benefits, including the retirement pension, means tested;

- a cut of one in six in public sector employment and a similar cut in public sector pensions (presumably excluding the army and police from the latter).

I’m simply not clear on Conservative economic policy in relation to government debt.

Simple really.

Since any sudden squeeze on government spending during the summer/autumn of 2010 might risk upsetting a fragile recovery
and sending us back into recession, Osborne/Cameron want to reassure everyone that any cuts in the short term will be ‘light’.

However, there is also a need to satisfy the markets that the incoming government is serious about getting the deficit down pretty soon. Failure to do so will send interest rates rocketing up.

Therefore the incoming government will have to ANNOUNCE cuts that will begin to bite on a tapered basis: not too much while the recovery still looks vulnerable; but vigourously and quickly once the recovery is secure.

Actually not so very different from what Alistair Darling would say if he didn’t have Brown/Balls on his shoulder trying to establish clear dividing lines for political reasons.

Cameron says, “We’re not talking about swingeing cuts.” I believe this to be literally true: they’re not talking about swingeing cuts.

And Osborne was going on about keeping interest rates as low as possible as being an objective, whilst also saying Labour presided over a massive increase in personal debt and we needed a new economic model.
I know nobody’s borrowing much at the moment, but I still don’t see those as very compatible. “Look, cheap money! Don’t use it though, you’ll only get into debt… Perhaps I can nudge you not to borrow…”
On the plus side, he had a much better knot in his tie than usual

A tight tail and the highest bid-to-cover ratio for eight years. It looks like those damn markets will just not conform to the Tory media narrative.

LONDON (Reuters) – Britain’s first auction since the Bank of England exhausted its 200 billion pound quantitative easing programme drew the highest bid-to-cover ratio in 8 years, more than three times the 3.75 billion pounds of bonds on offer.

Strategists had thought the sale would fare well as the bond was cheap compared with neighbouring securities on the curve, but the result surpassed expectations.

“It’s good for the market to get a post-QE auction under its belt and for it to go relatively well and be solidly received by the market,” said Moyeen Islam, strategist at Barclays Capital.

“For all the naysaysers on the gilt side, it seems to have held in relatively well.”


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Liberal Conspiracy

    What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/cqy8w3

  2. MyDavidCameron

    RT @libcon What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/aqRI7I < Good stuff from @BickerRecord

  3. Andrew Nix

    Liberal Conspiracy » What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/cqy8w3

  4. Malcolm Evison

    RT @mydavidcameron: RT @libcon What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/aqRI7I < Good stuff from @BickerRecord

  5. James Hepplestone

    RT @libcon: What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/cqy8w3

  6. vikz

    What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/bexACr (via feedly)(good question)

  7. Jose Aguiar

    Liberal Conspiracy » What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/cqy8w3

  8. uberVU - social comments

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by libcon: What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/cqy8w3...

  9. Who is your favourite Conservative? « Freethinking Economist

    [...] Nigel Lawson when the latter was Chancellor*.  He got in trouble with the Right of his party over grammar schools, questioning their sacred view that these schools are the key to social mobility, in a speech that [...]

  10. Steph

    Liberal Conspiracy » What exactly is Conservative economic policy? http://bit.ly/cqy8w3





Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

 
Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
RECENT OPINION ARTICLES




11 Comments



16 Comments



26 Comments



40 Comments



21 Comments



13 Comments



49 Comments



11 Comments



78 Comments



5 Comments



LATEST COMMENTS
» Tyler posted on Barclays was also bailed out - Diamond doesn't deserve a bonus

» Bob B posted on Barclays was also bailed out - Diamond doesn't deserve a bonus

» Bob B posted on Why Quantitative Easing doesn't make common sense

» michaela gabriel posted on High pay - in football and banking - shouldn't be about morality

» Frances_coppola posted on Why Quantitative Easing doesn't make common sense

» Meet My Sweet posted on Ed Miliband tried to persuade against Iraq

» x posted on High pay - in football and banking - shouldn't be about morality

» Stuart White posted on Paediatricians Assoc. members slams NHS bill

» Charlieman posted on High pay - in football and banking - shouldn't be about morality

» Charlieman posted on High pay - in football and banking - shouldn't be about morality

» Cylux posted on Abu Qatada deportation: what about our principles?

» Frances_coppola posted on Why Quantitative Easing doesn't make common sense

» Cylux posted on Abu Qatada deportation: what about our principles?

» Bob B posted on Ed Mili: We need a new post-Thatcher "settlement" for Britain

» diogenes posted on Why Quantitative Easing doesn't make common sense