Public: Marr wrong to ask about “pills”


by Newswire    
September 30, 2009 at 6:34 pm

A YouGov poll today said that a large majority of people – 73% – thought Andrew Marr was wrong to ask Gordon Brown whether he was taking prescription pills and/or anti-depressants.

They thought the Prime Minister had a right to privacy.

Only 22% said the public had a right to know Brown’s medical details.

Anthony Wells at UK Polling Report said:

I was actually rather surprised by that result – my expectation was that the general public attitude towards politicians is that they should jump through whatever humiliating hoops we demand. Looking at the queston wording, YouGov did specificy that the Prime Minister had a right to privacy on medical matters “that do not materially affect their work” and I suppose Andrew Marr would have said that the rumours, if true, could affect Brown’s work.

That said, 73% to 22% is pretty clear opposition to this sort of questioning.

                Post to del.icio.us

· About the author:

· Other posts by Newswire

· Filed under: news


14 Comments in response   ||  



Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Liberal Conspiracy

    Article:: Public: Marr wrong to ask about “pills” http://bit.ly/vzE90

  2. sunny hundal

    Britons not as prejudiced as Marr or Guido Fawkes RT @libcon: Public – Marr wrong to ask about "pills" http://bit.ly/vzE90

  3. Liberal Conspiracy

    Article:: Public: Marr wrong to ask about “pills” http://bit.ly/vzE90

  4. Liberal Conspiracy

    Article:: Public: Marr wrong to ask about "pills" http://bit.ly/vzE90

  5. Brown’s speech, the Elephant in the room « Freethinking Economist

    [...] Marr wrong to ask about pills [...]



Reader comments

I have been really quite stunned by the vitriol (especially over at Guido’s place). It’s been sickening that figures like Fawkes are taking the piss out of depression and mental health.

This poll result… in a small way… restores my faith.

Agreed. Some people are bastards, but people in general are quite nice too

“(especially over at Guido’s place)”

Kids can be cruel.

Joel @ 1

“stunned by the vitriol”

Why? Have you been living in a cave for the last thirty years?

Everyone knows the Tories have more than their fair share of vicious sub-human vermin and Staines et al are the epitome of the type of thuggery that they employ. If you are ‘stunned’ now wait to the bastards smell blood, they are worse than jackals.

Now that Cameron is now apaid lackey of the Murdoch press, it is going to get much worse.

Fawkes is a disgrace for the campaign he has been running on this.

6. Michael Read

Brown is an oddball with inappropriate behaviours which strongly suggest he is under medication.

Marr’s questions on this issue are quite proper, indeed it would be improper not to raise the questions.

The question should not be “is it right to ask about his mental health”, but “is it right to ask about his mental health based on the rumours of a couple of anti-Brown troublemakers”

@7, Michael Read. Evidence, please. There’s nothing strong to suggest he’s on medication, other than the scribblings of rumour-mongerers. He might be depressed, I’m not sure, but there’s nothing to suggest that’s affecting his work.

It’s just simply none of our business. But more than that, Guido’s using it to stigmatise mental health issues, which is just sick.

Brown made himself look ridiculous in response though and played into the hands of those critisicing him. He should have just laughed it off as nonsense (if it is, personally his record of lying is such I don’t trust a single thing he says).

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

 
Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or rss feeds.
Recent articles across Liberal Conspiracy
LibCon news

2 Comments 19 Comments 25 Comments 3 Comments 113 Comments 11 Comments 9 Comments 32 Comments 8 Comments 11 Comments

click here!



LATEST COMMENTS
» 5cc posted on Against multiculturalism

» Andy Walker posted on Ashok Kumar RIP

» cjcjc posted on Against multiculturalism

» Bob B posted on Contra Stimulus!

» links for 2010-03-15 « Embololalia posted on Lib Dems in a tangle over homeopathy

» Jim posted on Against multiculturalism

» Hibernica posted on Against multiculturalism

» LO posted on Against multiculturalism

» Mr S. Pill posted on Rogue Tory kills debt relief bill

» Alix posted on Fabians fail the Fairness Test

» soru posted on Against multiculturalism

» cjcjc posted on Against multiculturalism

» Stuart White posted on Fabians fail the Fairness Test

» LO posted on Against multiculturalism

» Jim posted on Who benefits from Lib Dem tax cuts?

  Last 50 // Comments feed