Deaths: spot the difference


by Unity    
11:37 am - April 8th 2009

      Share on Tumblr

Shoukat Ali, a north London businessman, died from a heart attack after chasing and confronting a thief he saw stealing a radio from his son’s car, police said yesterday.

Initial reports suggested Mr Ali died after being severely beaten by the thief but a post- mortem examination yesterday showed bruises on his body were inconsistent with that.

But the police said they were still treating his death as murder and appealing for witnesses. ‘In the pathologist’s opinion, the heart attack was brought on by the emotional and physical stress of chasing and confronting the thief. Mr Ali did have a recent history of heart disease,’ a spokeswoman said.

The Independent – 20 April 1994

Police have launched a murder enquiry following the death of a 95-year-old man knocked over and pinned down in his own home by burglars.

Ralph Platten was attacked earlier this week by thieves set on searching his home for money.

He was due to undergo an emergency operation on his broken hip yesterday, but police confirmed this morning that he had died in hospital overnight.

EDP 24 – 5 January 2006

A coroner gave a carefully worded verdict into the death of war veteran Ralph Platten today, making sure he recorded a direct link between the vicious attack on the 95-year-old and the day he died.

Norwich coroner William Armstrong made it clear there had been an “unbroken chain of causation” between the day Mr Platten was pinned to the floor by a gang of robbers – suffering a blow to the head and a fractured hip – and his death of a heart attack a day later…

…Recording a narrative verdict, Mr Armstrong said: “Ralph Platten died from a cardiac event following an appropriately performed medical operation which was necessarily carried out as a direct result of his receiving injuries as a consequence of an unlawful assault on him in his home.”

EDP24 – 29 August 2007

A POLICE officer convicted of assaulting a man shortly before he died is set to face a misconduct review.

PC Gary Jay will appear before an Essex Police disciplinary hearing after a failed appeal at Basildon Crown Court Jay assaulted Ronnie O’Reilly and his wife, Moira, at their home in Berkeley Road, Clacton, on July 14, 2007.

Mr O’Reilly collapsed in the kitchen and died of a heart attack on the way to hospital.

Nishan Wijeratne, a spokesman for Essex Police, said: “The incident involving PC Gary Jay is going to be reviewed against police misconduct regulations in order to identify whether any breaches of the code took place.”

Jay, who was based at Clacton at the time of the incident and later transferred to Colchester on desk duties, is suspended from Essex Police pending the internal hearing.

Clacton and Frinton Gazette – 24 March 2009

    Share on Tumblr   submit to reddit  


About the author
'Unity' is a regular contributor to Liberal Conspiracy. He also blogs at Ministry of Truth.
· Other posts by


Story Filed Under: Blog

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


Was anyone charged with murder for those 2 examples? If they caught anyone, what were they convicted of?


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Liberal Conspiracy

    New post: Spot the Difference http://tinyurl.com/cwq3ma

  2. Adem Djemil

    @paulfuller Also how is this assault any different from these http://bit.ly/10HKDU where a marder charge was called for ?

  3. Lee Griffin

    RT @libcon: New post: Spot the Difference http://tinyurl.com/cwq3ma

  4. Liberal Conspiracy

    New post: Spot the Difference http://tinyurl.com/cwq3ma

  5. Evan Davis: Apologist for Police Brutality? « Bad Conscience

    [...] Read this: Spot The Difference Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)G20 AftermathPolice Brutality At G20 – Man DeadNew [...]

  6. Adem Djemil

    @paulfuller Also how is this assault any different from these http://bit.ly/10HKDU where a marder charge was called for ?

  7. A New Challenger Appears » death in the city

    [...] here? Well, as Unity points out over at Liberal Conspiracy, the police in Britain have taken to treating criminal assaults which result in death as murder cases – even, in one case, where the heart attack that killed the man happened over 24 hours [...]

  8. Obstruction and Censorship At The G20 Murder « Ten Percent

    [...] else then what record to contradict the police falsehoods covering up Ian Tomlinson’s murder, the CCTV? The same CCTV that mysteriously stops working at crucial times & places when the [...]

  9. Links and stuff from between April 3rd and April 13th - Chicken Yoghurt

    [...] Liberal Conspiracy » Deaths:… – …spot the difference [...]

  10. More Police Brutality | The Big Blog

    [...] will know that there is something seriously wrong with policing and the law in this country. Have a read here and tell me how these differ apart from the fact that the attacker is a [...]

  11. A Third Post Mortem « Ten Percent

    [...] A Third Post Mortem 21 April, 2009 — RickB The cop’s briefs have gotten another post mortem granted (the third!)… anyway might it be worth contacting the IPCC and insist they have someone there too, after all they were barred from the first one (and again worth noting the double standards here). [...]





Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.