I have, in the past, been a great admirer of Peter Hain. Up to around about 2002/3 he was a strong progressive voice within government who was occasionally given licence to challenge the orthodoxy as when, for instance, he advocated a higher top rate of tax.
There is a plausible counterfactual argument for saying that, had he resigned with his old ally Robin Cook over the Iraq War in 2003, as his former admirers on the left would have expected him to, he could conceivably have mounted a successful challenge to Gordon Brown in 2007, standing as an experienced former minister on an anti-war ticket.
But it is clear that at some point around that time, Hain lost his balls. He failed to speak out against a war he must in his heart of hearts have opposed, and gradually, his left-field contributions to government policy-making dried up.
Never having been entirely trusted by the right and with his credibility on the left now badly compromised, it did not surprise me in the least that he performed so poorly in last year’s deputy leadership election, when he found his whole USP had been successfully purloined by Jon Cruddas.
For me, that is what is so tragi-comic about Hain’s current predicament – the fact that he spent £200,000 on a campaign which ended in near-humiliation for a man who once entertained serious aspirations to, if not the premiership, then certainly the Foreign Office.
Since then, he has gone on to win one small but important victory as Work and Pensions Secretary, overcoming Treasury objections to secure a £725m rescue package for 125,000 workers who lost pension rights when their employers went bust or wound up their schemes.
But even had the row over his campaign donations not occurred, I think it likely that he would have left the Cabinet at the next reshuffle, and hence I cannot help but think his time at the top of British politics is now drawing naturally to a close.
Who knows – if it meant Gordon could bring in Alan Milburn as Work and Pensions Secretary and stage a public rapprochement with the Blairites, then this is one crisis that the government might even be able to turn to its advantage?
Sunny’s update: Anthony Barnett at OurKingdom also weighs in on Hain’s future.
| Post to del.icio.us |
[...] not so Dizzy who tries to find the Mc behind the Man. PSS and now Paul Linford on Conspiracy, signals Iraq from a different [...]
The consequences of Hain leaving are clearly too awful for you ‘Liberals’ to contemplate.
Who knows – if it meant Gordon could bring in Alan Milburn as Work and Pensions Secretary and stage a public rapprochement with the Blairites, then this is one crisis that the government might even be able to turn to its advantage?
Very good point.
Justin makes a similar point to me, though he puts it rather more bluntly:
“Two hundred grand to be beaten in a popularity contest by Harriet bloody Harman? If I was him, I wouldn’t be wondering if it was worth carrying on in politics, I’d be pondering whether it was worth carrying on living.”
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
| 14 Comments 44 Comments 21 Comments 26 Comments 42 Comments 40 Comments 57 Comments 20 Comments 150 Comments 15 Comments | LATEST COMMENTS » Sunny H posted on Speculation that Tory PPC left due to pregnancy » Liberal Conspiracy » The myth of the New Labour carpetbagger posted on The rise of Labour's new class » David T posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. » Nina posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. » cjcjc posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. » David T posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. » pagar posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. » Senorviva posted on Speculation that Tory PPC left due to pregnancy » Sunny H posted on LC Investigation: Dorries claimed £70K for PR company services in 2½ Years » sevillista posted on Has the left won the first round in spending cuts? » andrew adams posted on Behind the BBC poll on climate change » Albert M. Bankment posted on Only 2 Tory MPs sign EDM accepting climate change » Tim J posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. » Tim J posted on Speculation that Tory PPC left due to pregnancy » David T posted on Women, political blogging and the future of the left. Last 50 // Comments feed |