I’ve not waded that much into the debate on Scotland’s future, partly because I’ve been focusing on ISIS and partly because its not my fight. I support the Union but its up to the people of Scotland to decide and they’re unlikely to be persuaded by this random guy from London. But I’m perplexed by […]
Last night President Obama delivered a speech on how the United States would tackle the threat of ISIS. It rightly deserves a lot of parsing and discussion.
There have broadly been two types of responses:
Both are wrong and exaggerated. Here are a few thoughts.
The Independent’s Partrick Cockburn writes: “West poised to join forces with President Assad in face of Islamic State”.
This is absolute rubbish. Not one British official is quoted saying they would work with Assad against ISIS. Not even anonymously.
When the British Foreign Secretary was asked on Friday by the BBC if the UK was planning to work with Assad against ISIS, he said “No” outright. He added that working with Assad would “poison what we are trying to achieve”. And said it was not “practical or sensible”.
The UK’s sole role in the Iraqi crisis so far has been to provide humanitarian aid. Military involvement would lead to demands for a vote in Parliament, and that’s not happened yet (and unlikely it will happen soon). So far, we are even refraining from air-strikes, let alone working with Assad.
Let’s get two caveats out of the way first: I’m neither a Muslim and nor am I religious in my daily life. I come from a Sikh family. Secondly, anyone who’s read my writing knows I have zero sympathy for religiously motivated terrorists. In fact I even supported the invasion of Afghanistan in 2001 to take out the Taliban. Now to the main point.
Yesterday the Evening Standard said in its Editorial Comment: “Muslim communities must be far more outspoken about this: we look to them, for instance, to organise protests against the Islamic State.”
It’s racist, and ridiculous.
There are three common rules when people discuss politics:
A recent example: the claim that Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi – the self proclaimed leader of Islamic State in Syria and Iraq – was funded or trained by the CIA or Israel’s Mossad, and that this was apparently revealed by Edward Snowden.
In the Observer today, I debate Nick Cohen on whether the Tricycle Theatre in London was right to ask the UK Jewish film festival to ‘reconsider’ its funding from the Israeli government.
There are two additional points I want to make that I didn’t have the space for.
If I had a penny for every time someone said this to me on Twitter, I’d have bought myself a min-island in the Bermuda by now.
Yes, the United States supports Israel with military aid every year. It also licenses American companies to sell Israel military equipment every year.
But Israel won’t collapse tomorrow if the US cut off their aid. Let’s just go over the numbers to explain.
A court judgement out this week sheds light on a very under-reported and rarely-discussed problem within South Asian communities in the UK.
In 2007 I reported for BBC Asian Network on women who come to the UK as brides from South Asia, and the potential problems they face. Since many don’t speak English (and are sometimes discouraged from learning it!) – they are more vulnerable to being abused, exploited, beaten or abandoned. One way to help, I argued, was to make it compulsory for them to learn English, so they could more easier seek help when needed and play an active role in British society.
Here are the facts of the case, as laid out in the court judgement.
The other day, in a discussion among friends on Israel’s attack on Gaza (I generally avoid them, even on Twitter), one said Hamas started the latest round of shelling by bombarding Israeli towns and inviting a response.
I have no way of verifying this, so I shrugged. Its irrelevant who started it.
On social media I’ve seen Israelis blame Hamas and say they’re merely defending themselves, so they’re justified in attacking Gaza. Israelis ask “what would you do if someone attacked you with rockets?“. Its a really stupid and short-termist question to ask and it misses the wood for the trees.
The Washington Institute recently published a note titled ‘The War Between ISIS and al-Qaeda for Supremacy of the Global Jihadist Movement’ – on tensions between the two movements.
Its worth emphasising briefly that there are differences between the two, mostly that ISIS are even more brutal than AQ and freely break many rules that Osama Bin Laden set for his own people.
But al Qaeda has effectively lost the battle for terrorism supremacy to ISIS / Islamic State.
Liberal Conspiracy is no longer a group blog. Read this post
» Doug posted on The Green Party has abandoned its key principle in support of Scotland's YES campaign
» douglas clark posted on The Green Party has abandoned its key principle in support of Scotland's YES campaign
» Ruby posted on The Green Party has abandoned its key principle in support of Scotland's YES campaign
» Grame Bird posted on The demand that more Muslims 'must condemn ISIS' is racist and ridiculous
» Ryan posted on The Green Party has abandoned its key principle in support of Scotland's YES campaign
» John posted on The Green Party has abandoned its key principle in support of Scotland's YES campaign
» Andreas Moser posted on The Green Party has abandoned its key principle in support of Scotland's YES campaign
» the a&e charge nurse posted on The demand that more Muslims 'must condemn ISIS' is racist and ridiculous
» Dr Paul posted on No, Obama is not taking the US to war in Iraq again (over ISIS)
» Dan McCurry posted on No, Obama is not taking the US to war in Iraq again (over ISIS)
» What would Labour do in 2015
» Adam Bienkov
» Adam Ramsay
» Anthony Barnett
» Beau Bo D'Or
» Carl Packman
» Cath Elliott
» Chris Dillow
» Claude Carpentieri
» Daily Quail
» Dave Osler
» Dave Semple
» Don Paskini
» Duncan Weldon
» Ellie Mae
» Huma Munshi
» Jamie K
» Jennifer O'Mahony
» John B
» Kate Belgrave
» Laurie Penny
» Lee Griffin
» Left Outside
» Leo Barasi
» Mat GB
» Neil Robertson
» Owen Jones
» Padraig Reidy
» Paul Cotterill
» Paul Hilder
» Paul Sagar
» Robert Sharp
» Sarah Ditum
» Shiraz Socialist
» Soho Politico
» Sue Marsh
» Sunder Katwala
» Sunny Hundal
» Mango Culture
» Tim Fenton
» Unity (MoT)
» DHgate's cheap products
» U.S. Congresspersons top list
» Finnish casino directory
» Milanoo.com: Online Fashion Shop for Dresses, Shoes & more!
» ChinaWholesaleCentral.com: The collections of online shopping websites from china » SCM; - a free way to enhance your writing skills.
» Enjoy top quality writing assistance at www.sierra-arts.net;